2. Why are Ahmadi Muslims not allowed to pray behind non-Ahmadi Muslims?
Question-and-answer session, 7 June 1991
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Why are Ahmadi Muslims not allowed to pray behind non-Ahmadi Muslims?
As-salamu alaykum. Wa alaikumus salam wa rahmatullah. Firstly, let me let you know that I am the Imam of the Mokani Mosque, and happily I am the Imam for the past 30 years. But there is something that bothers me a little, and I would like to have a little clarification on it. That is, that if I goes, as I am here this evening, invited to be present, and the time of Salah comes, I do not want to know whether the leader there is of the Ahmadiyya movement, whether the leader there is from the TML movement. Once he is there, and I recognizes him to be a Muslim, I am going to read Salah behind him. But the thing that bothers me most of all is that I have observed during the past few years—and I do not know whether this is a rule of the Ahmadiyya movement, I would like to know sir—that they do not read Salat behind any other Imam or any other person in the community. Thank you.
Please, if you have to ask another question, you may remain close. Sit down, take your seat here.
First of all, let me, with due apologies, observe that I think you know it already ever since you became an Ahmadi. Lahori Ahmadi? It’s not a question. Sunni Imam? I'm sorry, as you are a Sunni Imam, then I understand, because if you are a Lahori, I couldn't understand the question, because you should have known it already. So, I do apologies from me, I have misheard you.
So, you are a Sunni Imam. You say that you do not have to further question the sect or belonging of the person who is leading the Salat, because according to you, everything is all right. Whoever leads the Salat, you can say your Salat behind him. That is your position.
But before I explain my position, which is quite understandable, let me explain further that this is not the position of the official sects of Islam. All the sects of Islam have their own edict on this issue, and I have read widely the literature pertaining to different edicts, fatawa, and I haven't found a single sect in Islam which considers it permissible for their followers to follow the Namaz, Salat, behind another Imam.
So, because many people don't know these things, so they think it is all right, but officially, according to their sects, it is not all right. I will explain further, then you'll understand that it is not just a rebuking answer, it is a genuine answer.
For instance, if you have read the literature of Barelvis, they are the largest sect in India, run into hundreds of millions. Their Imam, Ahmad Raza Khan, has delivered his fatawa; they are published. In these fatawa he says that a Barelvi cannot say his prayer behind any other sect. If he does so, his prayer will go waste, it will not be accepted by God. But he goes further, much more than the Ahmadis have done. He says that if even if a non-Barelvi says his prayer behind a Barelvi Imam, that is not permissible. He says to shake hand with a non-Barelvi is un-Islamic. To marry with a non-Barelvi is un-Islamic. He says if a Barelvi... if a non-Barelvi marries a Barelvi, his children will not be valid, not not will not be legitimate, and so on and so forth. And the counter-fatawa of other sects are almost as severe as these, while as you are quite right, they have no right to say that we will not accept this Imam and that Imam and only we will follow the prayer behind our own sect. They have no legitimate reason.
Now I will explain why Ahmadis do not. And I understand, of course, if you ask the question generally, and I know you did, you will understand the answer. All the Muslim scholars belonging to all sects of Islam are united on one point, that Al-Imam Al-Mahdi is yet to come. Ahmadis believe he has come. They believe he has not yet come, but he will most certainly come. And they also agree on this, that Al-Imam Al-Mahdi will not be elected by the people, will not be appointed by an oil-rich state; he will be directly appointed by God. So they believe, and there is no exception, that if that Imam appears whom Allah has directly appointed, then those who reject an Imam appointed by God, they forfeit their right to lead the followers of that Imam. That is the clear position. On the one hand, an Imam has been appointed directly by God.
And a person, an ordinary Muslim, has the daring and audacity to reject that Imam. On the other hand, he expects that man-made Imam should be followed by the followers of that Imam. So, in that perspective only you can understand our position.
You believe Hazrat Mirza Sahib to be a false man. Although out of courtesy you may not say that in so many words. If you had believed that he was not false, you would follow him, you would join us. So, you believe that he was a false man. But we do not believe that. We believe he was directly appointed by Allah as that Imam which was promised to the Ummah 1400 years ago by Hazrat Muhammad Rasulullah (saw).
Now, what is our position? What will be your position, not today, but let's say tomorrow? Suppose the Imam does come. Suppose this is not the Imam, but the other Imam does come, and you follow him. And the other says that he is an impostor, he is a liar, he is outside the pale of Islam. Would your conscience permit you to say your prayers behind them? I ask you this question. If I were you, my conscience would not and does not.
So it's a question of how you look at this Imam, this claimant at least. If he is genuinely sent by God, this should be the genuine reaction. But this is not applicable to other sects. They have not been created by God as sects. Their aimma are not chosen by God and appointed by God. They have, in fact, created splits in Islam. They were all man-made. None of the sects claims to have been created by God as Jama'at.
So, as such, you are quite logical and right that no Muslim has a right to deny the Imamat of any other Muslim, whatever sect he belongs to. This is quite logical. But our case is different and I have explained the situation to you.