3. If a non-Ahmadi Muslim is elected to be an Imam, does that mean he is commissioned and guided by Allah?

Question-and-answer session, 7 June 1991

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: If a non-Ahmadi Muslim is elected to be an Imam, does that mean he is commissioned and guided by Allah?

Any other question, please? Yes.

Thank you. As-salamu alaykum. My question to Huzoor is: In the Holy Qur’an, it states, that whom Allah guides, there is none to lead him astray, and whom He leads astray, there is none to guide. If I happen to be an Imam, not of the Ahmadiyya Muslim, did Allah give me that mission to be an Imam? That is the question. Or, by whom I am permitted, or permission has been given to be an Imam?

That's a very good question, I'll answer you, please. Sit down.

You see, you are talking of the philosophy of Imamat. What is the philosophy that supports the system of Imamat? Where does one draw the authority? I have, in fact, answered it not directly but indirectly. The only Imam worthy of leading the people is the one appointed by God. And the rest of the a'imma we hear of, or we follow, we follow with the good hope that they are following the Imam. So, if they deviate from the path of the Imam appointed by Allah, then they forfeit their right to be Imams.

Now, the question whether Allah will punish them or not punish them lies with Allah, because the Holy Qur’an says: *Wa la tuzakku anfusakum, Huwa a'lamu biman-ittaqa.* Do, do not brag about your own taqwa and your own piety. Allah knows better. So we must not play God here.

The question is, very honestly and straightforwardly, if we see an Imam deviating from the path of an Imam created by God, that is Hazrat Muhammad Rasulullah (saw), then we will not follow him. Only then we consider that he is outside the mark. This is the normal, genuine position. But if everybody takes this into his own hands, then there will be chaos in the Ummah. Any Tom, Dick and Harry would say, "I think that Imam is outside the path set by Hazrat Muhammad Rasulullah."

That is why I quoted the other verse, to rectify the, the ultimate meaning from, to drive the meaning from both together. The other says: *Wa la tuzakku anfusakum, Huwa a'lamu biman-ittaqa.* Don't take pride of your taqwa over others, don't brag of it, be humble. Allah knows best who is truly muttaqi and who is not.

So, that is why Hazrat Rasulullah (saw) has forbidden people from refusing to say prayer behind an Imam who they consider is not righteous. He says that even if the Imam is a fasiq, but as long as he holds the office, nobody has a right to, not to follow him.

So this is exactly the system in our community we try to preserve very honestly and very diligently. If an Imam is considered to be less than capable, we do not permit the right to anybody to stop saying prayer behind him. We say: report the matter, it will be investigated and an inquiry will be held. If you're found to be right, then the Imam will be removed from office so that even others' prayer become good. It's not just your prayer for which the community cares; it's the prayers of all the members of the community. We can't permit everybody to deviate and run away and make his own mosque. That will start a process of split, which already you have had enough—fourteen centuries of splits and tragedy on this part, on, on, on, on this head.

So this is my answer to you: leave the question to the authority which appoints the Imam. Report the matter to him, if you do not agree with his character, and let the authority take the decision. After the decision is taken, submit yourself. Your prayer will not be lost even if the Imam is bad, because you will be following the instruction of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw); for his sake you will be doing it. So don't worry about your prayer, that will be accepted by God.

10 of 10 left today