4. If Ahmadi Muslims believe themselves to be guided by God, then wouldn't God accept their prayers even if they prayed behind a non-Ahmadi Muslim Imam?

Question-and-answer session, 7 June 1991

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: If Ahmadi Muslims believe themselves to be guided by God, then wouldn't God accept their prayers even if they prayed behind a non-Ahmadi Muslim Imam?

As you answered that question just now, that you follow the prayer of the Imam, and it is not your prayer that would be in vain, because you are following the directive of Rasulullah (saw), I am wondering whether in the same sense—that the, I am not condemning the Ahmadiyya Movement, I hope you understand—quite understand it, yes. In the same sense, whether the members of the Ahmadiyya movement can take the same type of understanding, and if the Imam there is of whether the Sunni school of thought, or whatever school of thought, and he is leading, and that you belong to the Ahmadiyya movement, and therefore you read behind him, your salah would be acceptable, whether what the position of the Imam there?

No, no, because in this regard there is another instruction of Rasulullah (saw). When I said that, I expected this question from you, quite honestly. I knew it was coming. And I also know the answer; I'm very clear on that.

Hazrat Rasulullah (saw) did not leave any room for any Muslim to reject the Imam Mahdi when he comes. So he said clearly that when you hear of the Imam Mahdi having appeared, even if you have to reach him on your knees across glaciers of ice, do that, and do bai'at at his hands.

So, the one who believes that such an Imam has come, what is his outlook on those who reject him and reject him very severely? According to them, they are not following the instruction of Hazrat Muhammad Rasulullah (saw).

Now, the position generally you can take is that you are wrong—we are wrong in accepting him, but not wrong in our logic. There are two different things. You are an educated person, you should distinguish between this and that. You are quite right, you have a right to say that Ahmadis have accepted a wrong Imam. But as long as they believe in that Imam to be from God, they are not permitted to say their prayer behind such a'imma who reject the Imam appointed by God. This is not a question of his being holy or unholy; this is a question referring to the authority.

So that is why I insisted on that word authority. In man-made Imams, the authority is a human authority. So you should refer to the authority. In God-made Imams—God-made Imams, the authority is Allah. So if somebody rejects that authority, no human authority can supersede that. So I am quite consistent in my answer.

I have no quarrel with that, sir.

No, no, I hope not, well, but you can ask another question, please.

No, no, no, I have no quarrel. All that all that I am trying to understand was, what was the reason behind the members of the Ahmadiyya movement not reading behind others?

Yes. In short, I repeat my answer. Our reasons are exactly, exactly the same as your reasons would be if, in your lifetime, the Imam comes and the society rejects him. I am quite certain, being honest to God, when you believe that Imam is appointed by God, you accept him, it will be impossible for you to say your prayer behind those who reject him.

As long as I am an Imam, I want to promise you that all people concern me. That I have no quarrel, whether Ahmadiyya, whether whoever they are, of course as to prayer, I am going to be part and parcel of whatever functions, and and I will read behind, and I will do everything, because I know within myself that, Imam, it is Allah that you are worshipping and therefore I will continue to bow in sajdah. Thank you very much.

You see, but still, you won't worship behind anyone who rejects Hazrat Muhammad Rasulullah (saw). Even if he is worshipping the same worshipping the same God—a Jew, for instance. He believes in God, he worships to Him, but you will never dare even once to worship behind him. The answer exactly in principle is the same, though the person differs here. The answer is, God is the same, but a Jew has the audacity to reject the Imam for all times to come, of the whole mankind. So he ceases the right to lead those who believe in that Imam. So vis-à-vis that Imam al-Mahdi, of course he is subordinate, there is no question, but you also believe him to be a subordinate. But he still is an Imam. The the principle is the same which applies to that.

Well, I think I have no further question, thank you.

Jazakallah, thank you. I know, I am really impressed by your nobility. You are a kind person and open-minded person. Otherwise you shouldn't have appeared here, I can see that. That's true, I can see that. That shows your attitude, I am grateful to you. But I have tried to explain to you as best as I can.

I do accept your explanation. Thank you.

10 of 10 left today