1. If we consider the Christians are part of the Ahle Kitab (People of the Book), then why doesn't Islam consider the Bible to be a book of religious law?

Question-and-answer session, 24 June 1991

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: If we consider the Christians are part of the Ahl-e-Kitab (People of the Book), then why doesn't Islam consider the Bible to be a book of religious law?

Assalamu Alaikum wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakatuhu.

Wa Alaikumus Salam wa Rahmatullah.

I was reading one of the passages from Hazrat Masih-e-Maud (as) in Malfuzat, Volume 7.

Right.

And I couldn't understand one of the passage. It would be very kind of you if you please do tell me what it is about. I'll read it in Urdu.

Right, right.

...We can't eat it. So this is why we can't use a variety of biscuits, but we can't use a Hindu company to do it. The next passage says:

عیسائیوں کی نسبت ہندوؤں کی حالت کچھ اس طرح کی ہے کیونکہ یہ اکثر کثرت سے ہم لوگوں میں مل جل رہتے ہیں اور ہر جگہ انہی کی دکانیں ہوتی ہیں۔ اگر مسلمانوں کی دکانیں موجود ہوں اور سب شئے وہاں سے ہی مل جائے تو پھر البتہ ان سے خوردنی اشیاء نہ خریدنی چاہیے۔ علاوہ ازیں میرے نزدیک اہل کتاب سے غالباً مراد یہودی ہی ہیں کیونکہ وہ کثرت سے اس وقت عرب میں آباد تھے اور قرآن شریف میں بار بار خطاب بھی انہی کو کیا گیا ہے اور صرف توریت ہی کتاب اس وقت تھی جو کہ حلت اور حرمت کے مسئلے بیان کر سکتی تھی اور یہود کا اس پر اس امر میں جیسے عملدرآمد اس وقت تھا ویسے ہی اب بھی ہے۔ انجیل کوئی شرعی کتاب نہیں ہے۔

On this note, Abu Saeed Sahib has announced that in the book of Al-Fazl, there is also an answer to this issue. Here I couldn't understand: if we consider Christians among the Ahl-e-Kitab, then all the Muslims or the Ahmadis at least...

I've got it, but why did you read such long passages when the only thing you wanted to ask was a simple question whether the Christians are Ahl-e-Kitab or not? You should, in future, pay regard to the value of time for all of people who gather here.

I'm sorry, Huzoor.

The simple thing is that when Hazrat Masih-e-Maud (as) says the real book of law is only the Jewish book, that is absolutely right and there is no confusion about it. This is what we have been arguing with Christians regarding Jesus' status in Judaism. We say he himself said that, "I have not come to change a jot of the book, but I have come to complete it," or perfect it, whatever—the wordings are not his, but this is the essence.

So, that is what we have been arguing throughout, that the book is Torah. And as such, Injil is not book, like al-Tadhkirah is not a book, in the sense that it is not a book of law. So, there is no confusion about it.

Regarding Christians being Ahl-e-Kitab, there is no doubt about it, that they are counted among the Jewish people. As such, they have no other book. So Hazrat Masih-e-Maud (as) when he said they have no book, he obviously meant that the only book they should be related to is the book of Torah. And that again is what we argue with the Christians, that show us where Jesus has told you to start eating pig, where he has, you know, permitted the eating of flesh of pig, while Torah did not do it earlier. Because Jesus did not bring a new law, he himself admits that. So unless he is told by God to change some law fractionally or partially, the Christians have no authority to change the book of Torah or the practice of Torah.

So that is in general what Masih-e-Maud (as) is discussing. But he does not mean that Christians should not be treated as Ahl-e-Kitab.

10 of 10 left today