6. Is meditation sufficient as a form of worship in Islam since people claim to be able to achieve the same result as salat?

Question-and-answer session, 1 July 1991

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Is meditation sufficient as a form of worship in Islam since people claim to be able to achieve the same result as salat?

On one occasion, while talking to a non-Ahmadi Muslim, I was not able to convince him about the difference between the prayers and meditation. He said to me that he does not offer prayers because he is able to seek the same result and consolation as one gets through prayers. I tried to put forward many arguments, but I request Huzoor to guide me as to what would be the best way to convince such a person that meditation is not as good as prayers, but we actually attain the love of God through prayers?

The person you are speaking about is a Muslim?

Yes, sir. Yes, Huzoor, he is a non-Ahmadi Muslim.

I understand. So, what is his opinion about the teachings of the Holy Qur’an and that of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw)? What does he think about that?

Yes, sir. Huzoor, he says he does not offer five times prayers, but he gets up in the early morning and reads Holy Qur’an.

I am not asking that. No, he believes in Holy Qur’an. So, show it from the Holy Qur’an that prescribed form of worship is essential, in which meditation is not mentioned, but whatever is mentioned, that is valid. Meditation is part of everything, not separate from the prayer described in the Holy Qur’an. In the Holy Qur’an, the prayer is described as *Qiyaman*—standing, *Qu'udan*—sitting, *Ruku'*, *Sajdah*. These are the four parts of the prayer which have been repeatedly described in the Holy Qur’an. So if he meditates during *Qiyam*, during *Ruku'*, during *Sajdah*, during *Qa'dah*, there is no harm. Anyone can and everyone should. But being outside the form described by the Holy Qur’an is not valid.

Only it will become valid if one performs this type of prayer as very clearly mentioned in the Holy Qur’an, and in addition to that, then he meditates. And that sort of meditation is mentioned in the Holy Qur’an as *Dhikr*: *Ulul-Albab alladhina yadhkurunallaha qiyaman wa qu'udan wa 'ala junubihim*. That meditation, that is a remembrance of Allah, can be done even lying down. So, but sitting and standing also. There, you should note that *Ruku'* and *Sajdah* are not mentioned, which means that the Holy Qur’an here is not discussing the formal prayer.

So there are two types of prayers mentioned in the Holy Qur’an; he has no right to choose one and reject the other, if he believes in the Holy Qur’an.

10 of 10 left today