4. We usually name our children Ghulam Mustafa or Ghulam Murtaza etc., but names like Muhammad Mustafa or Ahmad Mujtaba are not common. Is it permissible to give such names or not?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 30 August 1991
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: We usually name our children Ghulam Mustafa or Ghulam Murtaza etc., but names like Muhammad Mustafa or Ahmad Mujtaba are not common. Is it permissible to give such names or not?
When one gives the name Muhammad, that is already Mustafa; and the name Muhammad Mustafa does occur, also in Arabia. Personally, however, I prefer to avoid names that resemble the Holy Prophet (saw) too closely. The name Muhammad has become so common that it seems an ordinary name; but when one says Muhammad Mustafa, the remembrance becomes fresh again. Therefore I personally avoid it. I give the name Mustafa Ahmad; that I do give. But Muhammad Mustafa directly recalls the Holy Prophet (saw). Hazrat Muslih Mau’ud (ra) used to relate this incident: a man stole something and ran away; his name was Muhammad. Another ran after him and wanted to tell people he was a thief, shouting: Muhammad is a thief, Muhammad is a thief. [unclear] So such names fall into awkward situations; that is not respectful. The Promised Messiah (as) bore a name God had given him: Ghulam Ahmad, servant of Ahmad – that is how one should keep it.