12. [A woman's question:] My daughter is small. When films etc. are on, I forbid her and say Ahmadis don't do that; then she replies: why does so-and-so do such a thing?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 4 September 1991
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: [A woman's question:] My daughter is small. When films etc. are on, I forbid her and say Ahmadis don't do that; then she replies: why does so-and-so do such a thing?
First of all there is need for training in this matter. If a programme in films is watched once and one is saved from its evil, the harm is not as great as the harm of this filthy tendency: when someone gives advice, to retort 'Why does so-and-so do it?' The answer to that is: if so-and-so eats filth, will you eat filth too? This answer the girl has given is crookedness; correct it, otherwise it will remain so her whole life. Generally we have seen that when someone is advised, he retorts 'Why does so-and-so do it?' This means such a person closes the doors of advice on himself forever; he will remain deprived. First reform the more dangerous matter in this girl; other things will be looked at later.
Sometimes too much strictness about small family programmes causes harm. Children think these are very bigoted, ignorant people, and others are better [?]; then they secretly go with others and watch. You have to train, and training requires patience and also wisdom. When television was new, at first we did not have it at home. When I was about to install it, some friends said to me: this is such a thing that when children watch it, it will be bad; better not install it. An elder, now deceased, a quite respected personality, spoke to me himself and said: I do not like it at all. I told him: if my children do not watch at home, where I am also present and have the opportunity to tell them along the way 'this is absurd, see, there is nothing in it, and such-and-such is a good programme', then they will hide from my sight and go in the neighbourhood to the neighbours, to their relatives – where would I be there? And they will consider me a man of old times and consider those who give freedoms closer to them. Then the relationship with me will break forever, my word will lose its effect. I cannot commit this folly. So various programmes were on at my home; I sometimes sat a while, sometimes got up and left: this is a bad programme, turn it off [?]. Gradually, with love and explanation, by God's grace I got the opportunity to give better training than strict people give their children. So in training it is not only strictness; there must be wisdom, prayer, and more training should be given in those matters where crookedness is developing in a person. Even if you correct [other things], that crookedness will continue inside. This answer 'Why does so-and-so do it?' is intolerable. There are many follies in it. First: without asking whether this thing is bad, so I should stop, or not, simply saying 'so-and-so does it, therefore I will not stop' – this contains obstinacy, prejudice, bad manners. This answer is wrong. Second: have you taken the bai'at of so-and-so? Are you following so-and-so? The Holy Qur’an has mentioned the example of the Holy Prophet (saw) and of his Companions – that is the model. One should teach this answer: in my view the Holy Prophet (saw) used to say this, do this, therefore you have no right to stop me. That is a reasonable answer. But 'if, if, if – why should I not do it? Her name is also Ahmadi, I am also Ahmadi' – this is not a correct answer.
And if the questioner had in mind: I am a good Ahmadi, I do it like this, and so-and-so are bad Ahmadis – then that too is arrogance [?]. There are also weak ones; train them with love and affection, do not take pride over them that you are better and so-and-so are filthy, that they have put you in trouble, that they are spoiling your children. This is not a correct thing. Every person is himself the guardian of his own children. Pray, train with sincerity and humility, then nobody can cast a bad influence.