2. The second question is: Hazrat Jonah (as) prayed: “La ilaha illa Anta, Subhanaka, inni kuntu minaz-zalimin” (There is no god but You, holy are You, I was indeed among the wrongdoers). On the basis of this prayer Parwezi Sahib says that Hazrat Jonah was a wrongdoer (zalim), because he himself admitted that he was one. How can a prophet be a wrongdoer? That is my question.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 7 September 1991

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: The second question is: Hazrat Jonah (as) prayed: “La ilaha illa Anta, Subhanaka, inni kuntu minaz-zalimin” (There is no god but You, holy are You, I was indeed among the wrongdoers). On the basis of this prayer Parwezi Sahib says that Hazrat Jonah was a wrongdoer (zalim), because he himself admitted that he was one. How can a prophet be a wrongdoer? That is my question.

That is his ignorance. When a servant comes humbly before God and repents of his negligences, he uses such words about himself, even harsher ones. Regarding the Holy Prophet (saw) himself it is mentioned that he sought forgiveness for his “dhanb” (sins). What sins had he committed? So Parwezi Sahib should be careful when saying such things, to consider how far the matter will go. Out of humility the prophets see their weaknesses as very great. Every humble person who is inwardly moved truly sees his sin as great, whereas the one who is really a wrongdoer does not see it. Therefore the one who says “I am a wrongdoer” in fact has no wrongdoing in him when he says so. The wrongdoer sees nothing, because the word “zulm” derives from “zulmat” (darkness). A person who is in darkness about his own self sees none of his sins. I have often spoken with such people and tried to make them understand; they cannot see their own weakness. Hazrat Jonah committed an act that is evident, and everyone knows of it. It is permissible to say that Hazrat Jonah made this mistake and that he calls this mistake wrongdoing. But it is impermissible for us to sit and issue the verdict that Hazrat Jonah was a wrongdoer. The mistake is openly described in the Holy Qur’an, and one should open one's mouth only that far. Who dares to go beyond that? Have you understood?

10 of 10 left today