8. I would like to ask two questions. First question: in Islam the eating of certain things is forbidden, and not eating them has physical benefits besides spiritual ones. I would like to ask: according to modern science, what kind of benefits are there in not eating pork? [Huzur: You have made a statement; support it. You have not asked a question. You said that besides spiritual benefits there are also physical benefits of not eating it – tell me what they are.] That is exactly what I want to ask you.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 7 September 1991

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: I would like to ask two questions. First question: in Islam the eating of certain things is forbidden, and not eating them has physical benefits besides spiritual ones. I would like to ask: according to modern science, what kind of benefits are there in not eating pork? [Huzur: You have made a statement; support it. You have not asked a question. You said that besides spiritual benefits there are also physical benefits of not eating it – tell me what they are.] That is exactly what I want to ask you.

Look, in the discussion about pork one should stay within what the Holy Qur’an has said. It has only declared it impure (najis). If you search for impurity in this sense, the question of health does not come in. For when you raise the question of health, there are several other animals that are not forbidden, and you will be caught in the dilemma that eating the fat of such-and-such can also harm the heart. One could also say: what is wrong with eating lean pork? If there is no fat in it, what is the harm? Therefore these are mere hobby discussions with nothing solid in them. [Interjection: Norwegians often ask this.] By all means ask, but first listen to my answer. It has been called impure. Impure means that some of its habits are filthy and that there is a protest against these habits. Two things about this animal I have found after research which are definitely correct: first, among animals homosexuality is found most in the pig. Second, when the need arises it even eats its own young, although it is not a carnivore; that is, when its young die, it eats them too. These two habits are so unclean. I learned of the second habit when, during our farming, we had the problem of wild boars and how to kill them. A study came from America and a drug was recommended: if this drug is given to a piglet it will die, and its body … there were disease germs in it, I do not remember fully, but the point was a disease; some injection, and it dies of the disease. And the pig has the habit of eating its dead young. So when it eats, the disease spreads in it, and then other pigs start eating the pigs that die. So this is an extremely abhorrent habit, contrary to the ordinary, daily, natural habit: that a herbivorous animal eats the flesh of its brother, against which the Holy Qur’an has protested strongly. My impression, therefore, is that the protest against it is because it is impure in its habits. Once, in 1956 at the University of London, this discussion arose; we were sitting in the coffee room after the coffee break, all the students, girls and boys, were together. When I explained this, a girl stood up and asked what harm there is in homosexuality. I said: you have proven my point, that pork eaters do not see any harm, and that is precisely why it was forbidden. With your biased question – they say this habit cannot be transmitted to humans by eating the meat – by asking what harm there is in it, you have proven that the impure habit becomes so ingrained in those who eat it that they see no harm at all. And today this very debate has arisen in these regions: what difference does it make? Such people can even become ministers of religion; no harm. That is one wisdom. The second is a very great wisdom, even higher: Allah the Exalted is the Creator, and He has taught us that without My permission – it is not only about the pig – you may not kill any animal. The animal has a sanctity of its own. That is why for the animals we are permitted to slaughter, we are enjoined to recite “Bismillah, Allahu Akbar” beforehand, as a reminder that I am doing this with the Owner's permission; of my own accord I have no right to take any life. Likewise, when harmful insects are killed, there are already instructions on that: to the extent that something is harmful to man, it may be killed; that comes under self-defence. But killing animals of the in-between kind was not approved even by the Holy Prophet (saw). The Promised Messiah (as) very strictly forbade children: you have no right to kill animals that were not made for eating – crows or other small bulbuls, beautiful little birds; he forbade that. So this is a basic principle of Islam: life is God's property, life must be respected, and no one's blood may be taken without God's permission. Now Allah the Exalted forbids one animal, that it is not to be eaten; He is the Owner, it is His right. If you eat it, all the things you eat become taken by force, not with permission, matters of might is right, like a man who steals even when he has no right. But if you stop where you are stopped, all things become lawful and subject to permission. The basic principle is: does the Owner have the right or not? The only question is whether God is the Owner or not. If He is the Owner and says, eat this and that, the rest I do not let you eat, what right does the servant have to say: prove to us why we should not eat it? This one prohibition taught us a very precious principle: that whatever we do, we do with permission, and where there is no permission one should stop. When you explain this to them you will find that these questions mostly stem from atheism, because they have no concept of God and no faith in Him at all. They think we abstain out of superstition, and unless it is explained scientifically why we abstain, they will not abstain. Our stance for abstaining is entirely different; there is no scientific basis here at all. Even if I gave a scientific reason today, why did the Muslims of fourteen centuries abstain? And how far will my voice reach in the whole Islamic world? Therefore this debate is completely irrelevant. Discover scientific things out of interest and hobby as you like, but abstaining is a result of the commandment. And the biggest point is that this prohibition applies also to those who are eating it. One should ask them in return: Islam came third; first Judaism forbade it, and Hazrat Jesus did not make it lawful – show where he made it lawful. So first you tell us why it was forbidden in Judaism; prove it rationally, then we will see whether the reasons are sensible or not. We abstain because God said so. If you want to abstain with understanding, then first explain the philosophy of Judaism and explain why, despite Hazrat Jesus not permitting it, you declared a forbidden thing lawful. What is your authority for that? Understood?

10 of 10 left today