10. The question concerns the environment and society here: if we have no job, we receive unemployment allowance. The question is: if we deliberately do not want to work, will that income be lawful (halal)? And together with this another … [Follow-up: if someone is offered taxable work and does not take it …]

Urdu question-and-answer session, 7 September 1991

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: The question concerns the environment and society here: if we have no job, we receive unemployment allowance. The question is: if we deliberately do not want to work, will that income be lawful (halal)? And together with this another … [Follow-up: if someone is offered taxable work and does not take it …]

First let us settle the question of lawful income; then we will talk about the rest. Whatever is based on falsehood acquires an impurity. The only question is against whom one is sinning – the government or directly God. Thus there are degrees in sins; some become relatively lighter, some heavier. But the fundamentally decisive point is that a person, out of a crooked disposition, has deceived his own self, wronged himself, and also deceived the government. He has deceived, and deception is in any case an offence, and this offence of deceiving is an offence against one's own self and also against God. So for a person who has the capacity to work, righteousness and his decency demand that he work. If he gets something without lacking ability, it is not charity. For these nations have raised taxes so much that there is a kind of insurance on behalf of society: whoever is deprived of work – since you as a nation in general pay high taxes, a part of it will go to your needy brothers – because it is a national responsibility that no one goes hungry and no one is deprived of basic needs. This is the principle. Therefore for a person who is genuinely without work and cannot find work, this is neither alms nor a favour; it is his national right. But for one who takes it unlawfully it will not remain a right; it will become theft. Theft remains theft in whatever form one commits it. Understood? Besides, it is also great foolishness to sit idle for no reason and live off something; I do not understand what kind of people do such a thing. [Follow-up] There is no need to ask questions about the details. We have stated the principle. Now if you start accusing someone, without naming him, who does not work – leave this quarrel. The principle has been stated; the matter is closed. Beyond that every person has his own conscience; he knows best. We have no right to interfere in anyone's affairs to the extent of saying: you could work and you are not doing so. That is for him and God, for him and the government to know. My task was to give the decision of principle, and I have done that. After this I will not give detailed answers.

10 of 10 left today