12. Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullah. Huzur, my question concerns the present politics of Pakistan, the phase it is going through. After the defeat of Iraq you said in sermons about Iraq that these conditions can befall any Muslim country. [Huzur: Right; in fact they will come in turn.] After the defeat of Iraq, George Bush declared that he would give the world a new world order. And according to current news, America has prepared a formula for an independent Kashmir under which it will join neither India nor Pakistan. [Huzur: Who told you? From which news?] From Pakistani news, the newspaper Jang; Mahmood Sham, a columnist, wrote it. He reasoned that America no longer needs Pakistan since the Geneva Accord. Because of enmity towards Muslims it seems that similar conditions will befall Pakistan. Supposing America really is preparing such a formula and Pakistan does not accept it – what conditions could Pakistan face?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 7 September 1991
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullah. Huzur, my question concerns the present politics of Pakistan, the phase it is going through. After the defeat of Iraq you said in sermons about Iraq that these conditions can befall any Muslim country. [Huzur: Right; in fact they will come in turn.] After the defeat of Iraq, George Bush declared that he would give the world a new world order. And according to current news, America has prepared a formula for an independent Kashmir under which it will join neither India nor Pakistan. [Huzur: Who told you? From which news?] From Pakistani news, the newspaper Jang; Mahmood Sham, a columnist, wrote it. He reasoned that America no longer needs Pakistan since the Geneva Accord. Because of enmity towards Muslims it seems that similar conditions will befall Pakistan. Supposing America really is preparing such a formula and Pakistan does not accept it – what conditions could Pakistan face?
[Interim replies:] People follow Mahmood Sham's statements needlessly. As long as he gives no proof, no reference from which he has deduced it, it is his political commentary that it may have happened this way – or is it news that has reached him? That is what I am asking. It is a commentary, it has no more reality than that. Where is the enmity towards Muslims in this? If America has decided to make Kashmir independent – which is not far-fetched, I am not denying it – I am only saying it should not be called news; it should be called commentary, an observer's opinion. I too expressed opinions, but I did not call them news. So it is a possibility, but it cannot be called enmity towards Muslims. How does it become enmity towards Muslims? A Muslim majority is being crushed under India's oppression and tyranny, and the conditions are very painful. If they are made independent, how can that be called enmity towards Islam or towards Muslims? I cannot understand that. Before talking about Pakistan, talk about Kashmir: Kashmir will still get independence, won't it? So what enmity towards Muslims would there be? What right does Pakistan have to occupy Kashmir by force? Strange: if India has no right, neither has Pakistan. [Objection: there are elements who want it joined with Pakistan.] Those are elements; the question is what the Kashmiri says. As far as I have assessed and asked Ahmadis in writing, they say that the overwhelming majority there wants complete freedom and does not want accession to Pakistan. Only the Jamaat-e-Islami, and now some agents of Pakistan are coming and spreading propaganda in order to bring about accession to Pakistan. That is the situation. I am neither against accession nor in favour of it. I am only in favour of one principle: if Kashmir is to get freedom, it must be as a result of the right of self-determination; otherwise it has no meaning. And if self-determination is to be granted, then ask them what they want. Therefore, until a referendum is held in Kashmir on whether they want to remain completely independent of both the State of Pakistan and the State of India, or want accession to one of them, nothing should be imposed on them. Just as India had no right to rule over Kashmir until now, Pakistan likewise has no right to annex Kashmir to itself by force. Do you understand or not? Therefore, if America takes a step in favour of the right of self-determination of the inhabitants of Kashmir, America cannot be called unjust in this matter. We are not the enemies of any one country. We criticise America to the extent, and very boldly, that it makes wrong decisions. To assume that we have become opponents of America and must declare everything it does wrong would be utterly foolish; we would depart from our own position. Islam has taught us to remain firm on justice, and so much so that even against the enemy you must not depart from justice: that the enmity of a people should never incite you to depart from justice even by a hair's breadth. How clear a teaching that is! So whenever you make political comments or reflect, never speak out of friendship or enmity towards any country, or out of being Pakistani or non-Pakistani; rise above these things and never let yourself be entangled in them. Otherwise your judgements will be wrong. One must see what righteousness and justice demand. If Pakistan departs from this, it is your duty to criticise Pakistan – not that, against India, if Pakistan commits some wrong, you support Pakistan. What kind of justice is that? Ahmadiyyat is an Islamic understanding of a global nature, and Islam, being global, can neither support any nation nor any colour nor any geographical region. It is international. So when you think about international matters, forget your Pakistani identity. But your Islamic identity you can never forget. If you think in this way, much light will arise in your mind, your mind will be freed from many entanglements, and as a result of standing firm on righteousness Allah the Exalted then grants further light. Do you understand? Therefore it is not permissible that, without reason, just because you are Pakistani, you start thinking of enslaving the Kashmiris for Pakistan's sake. These people have the habit of crying enmity towards Muslims about everything with closed eyes. Some things are not enmity towards Muslims but a factual necessity. Why should we call them enmity towards Muslims? Understood?