19. When a child is born, is its lifespan decided at the time of birth? Who decides – Allah decides at what age this child will die. Why does He decide so? … It is about knowledge.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 7 September 1991
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: When a child is born, is its lifespan decided at the time of birth? Who decides – Allah decides at what age this child will die. Why does He decide so? … It is about knowledge.
Yes, I will explain. If this decision were such that something is simply written in advance, it would have no wisdom. If it is related to the child's lifestyle, its weaknesses, its illnesses and the assessment of its health, the nature of the decision changes completely. For example, when an engineer builds a bridge, he decides it will last from such a year to such a year. He is not deciding its death; he is estimating the bridge's life, and in this estimate there is sometimes a difference of ten or twenty years. His decision is not based on wanting the bridge to be destroyed in 1920 or 2020. What is meant is: the material used, the traffic that will use it, the hazards, the soil beneath it, the storms that will pass, the weather effects – I compute all of these and estimate that in such a year the bridge will be destroyed. Is there a difference between these two things? (Yes.) In one case a destiny is made of itself without any reason, that the bridge be destroyed on a certain date, whether its condition is good or not, and as a result it will necessarily be destroyed. The other is the decision of a wise person keeping all circumstances in view, in which he has also given freedom and knows how the thing will use that freedom. This is a destiny of an entirely different nature. The decision about a child's birth, as far as I have understood, is of this second kind. Allah knows about every child what health it has, what health its parents have, what germs are in it, what weaknesses its cells have. If a human had knowledge of the present in all its finest details, not of one thing but of everything, his computation would be perfect. Take an accident: you will set off at a certain time, and if it is also known that someone else will set off at a certain time and his mental state is such that at a certain time he will fall asleep – whoever feeds the computer so precisely, his computer will give the correct result. So Allah's being Knower of the unseen is connected with His knowing all that exists. Because He has perfect knowledge, knowledge of the future is a self-evident result of it; He necessarily had to have it. With such vast knowledge it is not the least bit difficult for Allah to know about a newborn child what its physical condition is, what the economic circumstances of its parents and environment will be – if all details are known, of economic crises too, and of the temperaments of the family. Such fine knowledge is needed that even imagining it would make the human mind break down; but God has it. So Allah can decide on the basis of knowledge that this child's life will reach such a limit. If the decision was made on this basis, then there is room for prayer. Then you can change its destiny through prayer and say to God: if left to itself this child would have died of this cancer; Your decision was right, but You are All-Powerful, we beseech You to set the higher decree in motion and save this child. Then God's higher decree will come into action. His two decrees will not collide, because the first had other reasons; it was not God's wish that it must die. The second is the decree of wish, of will, and it prevails over the general decree. That is why the Promised Messiah (as) made divisions on the subject of destiny and said that some decrees are 'kharq-e-adat' (extraordinary, breaking the norm) – this is the idiom of the Promised Messiah (as). Kharq-e-adat means that Allah, departing from the general law of nature, makes a higher decision which necessarily prevails over the law of nature, because the law is also His and this higher decision is also His. But he said this extraordinary decree is not applied for everyone; rather those people benefit from it who bring about extraordinary changes within themselves and in their dealings with Allah or His creation. There are ordinary relations with God, daily ones according to His Shariah, and with mankind. If you keep to those, you have no right that God change His general circumstances for you. But if your sacrifices for God and for His sake depart from normal human custom and acquire extraordinary significance, then God shows an extraordinary decree for you as well. Understood? (Questioner: I have understood. I return to my point: it is said that not even a leaf can move without Allah's will.) That is also right; He does what He wills. But when He says: I permit you, do what you wish – will it then happen with His permission or without? With permission. He has indeed said: 'Whoever wills, let him believe, and whoever wills, let him disbelieve' – whoever wishes may disbelieve, whoever wishes may hold to the truth. Therefore it is wrong to say that one who disbelieves does so without permission; but it is also wrong to say he does it according to God's wish. That is why I explained these two things separately, because I knew you would fall into such confusions. The decree of wish is one thing and the decree of knowledge another. Allah decided: I give permission – that is one decree made manifest. But it is not Allah's wish that some people commit filth and some rebel against Him. As a result of the permission it can be said that without permission they could not have done it. But responsibility for their deeds will not fall on the one who gave permission, because He did not wish that they do it. In school, when teachers teach, the child has a kind of permission: to study more or less, attentively or inattentively; otherwise there would be endless interference in every matter. As a result of this permission the teacher fails some children. Whose fault is it – the one who gave permission or the one who misused it? A similar relationship of destiny exists in some matters with Allah as well.