20. As you just said: sometimes He wants something to happen. For example, a man does wrong, say against Islam, and his end comes: another man quarrels with him over something and kills him. Actually Allah decided that his life be ended. Is the man through whom this happened, in which Allah's will was involved, also guilty?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 7 September 1991
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: As you just said: sometimes He wants something to happen. For example, a man does wrong, say against Islam, and his end comes: another man quarrels with him over something and kills him. Actually Allah decided that his life be ended. Is the man through whom this happened, in which Allah's will was involved, also guilty?
The reason is that the person to whom Allah gave this permission also had his own intentions, and he will be recompensed according to those intentions. One who kills with the intention that it is Allah's command – as the Muslims killed others in war – his act of killing became praiseworthy because of his intention. But one who kills with evil intent, even if the act in itself is good, insofar as that person is concerned he will certainly be punished, while the event itself turns out good. A man by mistake, or culpably, kills a murderer – the murderer has received his punishment, hasn't he? But if the law had not given that man authority, he too will be arrested. So he will be recompensed according to his intention. (Questioner: It may also be that he deserved this punishment due to other sins and Allah used him, just as governments sometimes use criminals against criminals.) Yes, exactly. But if he is caught, he is also punished.