22. One more question for information, for everyone: when we offer prayer in congregation and a mistake occurs – the Imam does only one prostration, we follow behind, the Imam doesn't remember, but someone in the row behind realises the Imam did one prostration and forgot the second. After he has said the Salam, he is told from behind: you did only one prostration. Can everyone then do the prostration, or after the Salam is nothing possible?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 7 September 1991

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: One more question for information, for everyone: when we offer prayer in congregation and a mistake occurs – the Imam does only one prostration, we follow behind, the Imam doesn't remember, but someone in the row behind realises the Imam did one prostration and forgot the second. After he has said the Salam, he is told from behind: you did only one prostration. Can everyone then do the prostration, or after the Salam is nothing possible?

This is a very clear matter. I'll tell you the principle: if the mistake is in something that is not a Rukn (essential part), only Sajda Sahw (prostration of forgetfulness) should be done. If it is pointed out after the Salam, it is the Imam's duty to perform Sajda Sahw and the Muqtadis go into prostration with him. If a Rukn was missed, the Rukn is also performed and Sajda Sahw is also done. There are several cases: one who prayed five Rak'at instead of four cannot undo the Rak'a prayed; he will only do Sajda Sahw. One who prayed three instead of four will pray one Rak'a and also do Sajda Sahw. If one prostration was done, he will do the second one as well and also the two prostrations of Sajda Sahw. Understood? And the rule here is: if the Imam goes into Sajda Sahw and some Muqtadis have already stood up to complete the rest of their prayer, in whatever position they are they should fall into prostration and prostrate with the Imam. When the Imam says the Salam, they return to their previous position, where they were standing or in Ruku'. Even if they were in Ruku' and had not yet said 'Sami'allahu liman hamidah', they go from Ruku' straight into prostration, and when the Imam finishes the prostration and says Salam, they go back into Ruku'. Those Muqtadis behind the Imam [still completing] will not say Salam; the Salam is only for those who did the Ruku' with the Imam and are to finish with him. The rest remain in the state of prayer.

10 of 10 left today