24. My question concerns Witr. One says Salam after two Rak'at and then prays the third Rak'a and says Salam again. But if after two Rak'at someone talks to somebody or changes his place and goes elsewhere, will these two Rak'at count, or will he have to pray all three at one time?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 7 September 1991
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: My question concerns Witr. One says Salam after two Rak'at and then prays the third Rak'a and says Salam again. But if after two Rak'at someone talks to somebody or changes his place and goes elsewhere, will these two Rak'at count, or will he have to pray all three at one time?
Once you say Salam you are no longer in that state. But since the next Rak'a was part of it and that part is being prayed separately, reason demands that between these two states one should not talk of other things or turn one's attention away. But if, for example, someone forgot his cap and after two Rak'at remembers, fetches the cap or makes some other necessary movement, one cannot give the verdict that his prayer is broken. His prayer remains intact until he makes the intention for Witr again. Necessary movements in the intervening time will not be considered disruptive to the prayer. But ordinary reason, common sense, demands that since this was originally one thing and two parts of a single whole are being performed, no break should be inserted and mental continuity should be maintained. (Questioner: In Masjid Nasir, Rabwah, Sufi Basharat Ahmad Sahib was teaching and said that if after two Rak'at a person talks to someone or changes place, he must pray all three Rak'at again.) Did you ask him what the Sunnah for it is? He must have given some reference. (I don't remember.) I will look into it. If I don't know it and he knows, I will change my advice. I said this because by my estimate and knowledge there is no clear injunction about it, and when there is no clear injunction one speaks by common sense. And common sense, as I understood it, demands that except in necessity one should not do anything else in between. But since a small interval is given in between – otherwise the Salam would have no meaning and the renewed intention would have no meaning – one should consider this too. You should have asked him: if the same state of three Rak'at continues, why is the Salam said and the intention made again? You should have asked for such a reference. I will find out. Who is this – someone from our travelling party? Write right away to Sufi Basharat Ahmad Sahib and ask: is this Fatwa your personal inclination or is there an authority for it? And he should write which authority it is, so that I can research it.