25. The question is: God says, I cover your sins, so you cover people's sins. Where in the Holy Qur’an has God said this, that He covers faults?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 7 September 1991
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: The question is: God says, I cover your sins, so you cover people's sins. Where in the Holy Qur’an has God said this, that He covers faults?
Where has God Almighty said this? It is not in my knowledge, in the form 'I cover your [faults], so you cover those of people'. Do not attribute it to God. You may state it as an inference (Istinbat). The elders say Allah treats every person as he treats the servants of God. This is an inference from sayings of the Holy Prophet (saw) such as: 'Whoever does not show mercy to people, Allah does not show mercy to him.' In this sense you can state it as an inference, but do not say that God says: if you cover, I will cover. God has not said that anywhere. An inference is possible, i.e. you can draw the conclusion from some Ahadith and some verses of the Holy Qur’an and expect that a servant of God who shows good qualities in certain matters will be treated by Allah in those matters accordingly, in consideration of his good qualities. Of those who expose others' faults, for example, there is less expectation that God will cover theirs. These are the demands of reason; speak accordingly. But not even a minor thing should be attributed to God which He has not said that way. Understood? I am presenting this as a theme, not that God said it so. (Questioner: To what extent?) God has not said it in that sense at all, so what is the question of 'to what extent'? It is a principle: if a person has a good quality in some matter, he is shown consideration in that matter. It is human nature: as someone treats you, you treat him. If someone treats your children well, then in that matter even if he errs you will overlook it and treat him gently. God has created man upon His own nature, so Allah too would treat His servants the same way – this is the demand of reason. To what extent is for Him to decide: how far the servant has gone crooked, how far the faults are forgivable – these decisions are God's; we cannot say anything about it.