2. Dr. Mahmood Ahmad, Malerkotla; I am currently doing my MD in medicine in Jaipur. The present economic system is such that interest has become compulsory in a way; there are other things in which shareholders have a share, and one has to take insurance, there are compulsory government insurances. This sometimes causes hesitation, because the Shariah of Muhammad declares interest forbidden, and insurance policies etc. also involve some interest. Please explain a little.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 18 December 1991
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Dr. Mahmood Ahmad, Malerkotla; I am currently doing my MD in medicine in Jaipur. The present economic system is such that interest has become compulsory in a way; there are other things in which shareholders have a share, and one has to take insurance, there are compulsory government insurances. This sometimes causes hesitation, because the Shariah of Muhammad declares interest forbidden, and insurance policies etc. also involve some interest. Please explain a little.
Look, you are mixing two things. The issue of insurance is separate, and the issue of the interest-based banking system is separate. There was a time when insurance and interest were so intertwined that one could not be separated from the other. Every insurance contained an element of interest and also an element of gambling. Therefore those conditions made all insurance forbidden. Later gradual changes occurred, and today’s insurance – many of its kinds at least, some still not – falls neither under the definition of interest nor under that of gambling. For the definition of gambling is that either you lose everything or you get much more than you gave. Losing everything is part of the definition of gambling, and at one time the basis of insurance was exactly this: either you lose everything, or if you die early you get much more than you gave, and if you don’t die early you lose everything. When such conditions were presented to the Masih-e-Mau’ud (as) at that time, he said there was gambling in it and also an element of interest, because profit on the accumulated sum was paid as interest; so both were forbidden. Now non-interest insurance is available to everyone; everyone has the choice to take interest on his money and insure on such terms, or not. So when there is a choice, the interest part can be avoided, it can be disregarded. And the further condition of insurance that if you stay alive you will not lose everything but will surely get back what you gave also removes it from the definition of gambling. Therefore the fatwa of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat issued about fifteen years ago in the time of Hazrat Khalifatul Masih III (rh) is that the present form of insurance, in many of its forms, is not forbidden. But we do not leave this decision to individuals, because they would make mistakes and, following their desires, could decide wrongly. Hence the procedure is that whoever wishes to take insurance should write to the Mufti of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat, clearly stating the conditions on which he wants to insure. Hazrat Khalifatul Masih III (rh) had formed a committee there of which I was also a member, a three-member committee: Maulvi …, the Mufti-e-Silsila, and myself; this committee was to decide whether the conditions contain an element of interest or gambling or not. But inquiries did not come from people, and many made decisions on their own. Later I did not insist on it, because it would have become very difficult. Since the matter has been thoroughly clarified and truth and falsehood can be distinguished, Ahmadis themselves should, avoiding the elements of gambling and interest, take whatever insurance they can, by all means. As for the interest-based financial system, it is a very broad question; if I start the answer now it will become a long story. I have spoken a lot on this before, and recently in the address I gave in England, ‘Islam’s Response to Contemporary Issues’, I discussed it in one part. That lecture is close to being printed; when it comes, inshaAllah it will become clear to you that the interest system does not win and cannot win, but will necessarily lead mankind ultimately to destruction. What the economic evidence for this is, I have discussed there. Since it is a very long and deep piece, I do not want to say anything more about it now.