21. Huzur, my name is Ashiq Hussain, I am from Kashmir. My dear friend Tanvir Ahmad Khan Sahib and Maulvi … Sahib told me before the meeting that I am receiving Tabligh; please pray. I want to ask: what is called Jihad, and how many kinds of Jihad are there?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 18 December 1991

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Huzur, my name is Ashiq Hussain, I am from Kashmir. My dear friend Tanvir Ahmad Khan Sahib and Maulvi … Sahib told me before the meeting that I am receiving Tabligh; please pray. I want to ask: what is called Jihad, and how many kinds of Jihad are there?

The first kind of Jihad is the one the Holy Qur’an described in the verse 'wa jahidhum bihi jihadan kabira' – strive with the Holy Qur’an a great Jihad. So the great Jihad, the greatest and mightiest Jihad, is spreading the teaching of the Holy Qur’an in the world. The lesser Jihad in comparison, of second rank, is the Jihad of the self, and that too is superior to the Jihad of the outward sword. The Jihad of third rank is when, as a result of religious difference, an enemy raises the sword against you and you are compelled to answer him with the sword. This too falls within the kinds of Jihad. But when the Holy Qur’an gave permission for the first time, it did not call it Jihad there, but Qital (fighting). [In Sura Jumu‘a] it came, where permission was given for the first time for what we consider Jihad – what some scholars consider Jihad … All scholars agree: this is the verse of Sura Al-Hajj which in their view gave permission for Jihad for the first time, yet the word Jihad is not used; the word is Qital. He says: permission is given to those to raise the sword in response against whom the enemies have already raised the sword. And with this permission Allah assures: 'wa innallaha ‘ala nasrihim laqadir' – Allah has power to help them. So the kind of Jihad called Qital is conditional: conditional on the enemy first attacking you with outward weapons and taking the lead in compulsion. In every kind of Jihad the basic spirit and basic philosophy of justice is the same: with the weapon the enemy attacks you, you have the right to use against him. If the enemy comes with arguments, confront him with arguments; if he attacks with exhortation, answer him with better exhortation; if he raises the sword, the Holy Qur’an says, it is your basic right to raise the sword against the sword. All the kinds of Jihad are covered by this. The middle kind, Jihad against the self, is mentioned in the Hadith of the Messenger of Allah (saw): once, returning from a battle, the Messenger of Allah (saw) said: we are now returning from the lesser Jihad to the greater Jihad – that is, the Jihad of training our own selves and the Jihad of preaching. This Hadith declared both these Jihads superior to the Jihad of the sword. So when the Messenger of Allah (saw) calls it better and declares it superior, who is anyone to declare it lesser? Understood? But the term Jihad in this sense will necessarily apply only to fighting that arises as a result of religious difference. This does not mean Muslims are not permitted other fights, but the craze for calling other fights Jihad is not right; there is no precedent for it in the Holy Qur’an. Now there is fighting in Kashmir; it is a war of independence for which a political justification is put forward. Calling it Jihad in the religious sense is not right. A Jihad in another sense – there is a Hadith of the Messenger of Allah (saw) which in fact applies equally to every human being in the world, with no distinction between Muslims and non-Muslims: whoever is killed defending his right, he called him a kind of martyr too; whoever drowns, he called a martyr too. Now among those who drown are Hindus, Sikhs, Muslims, Christians; sinful, wicked Muslims also drown – all of them become martyrs. It means that an extraordinary death, distinct from other deaths, has occurred, so it was given the title of martyr; but in the technical sense he is not a martyr. Do you understand? In the technical sense the martyr is only the one who dies for the faith. So you may apply Jihad in the general sense to Kashmir or to Rajputana, that is your matter of taste; in the technical sense of the Shariah there is only the Jihad the Holy Qur’an defined: if a people prevents you from acting on your religious beliefs, uses the sword in doing so and punishes you for acting on your religious beliefs – if you then fight, that is Jihad. And for this Jihad He set a sign by which anyone can recognise it: 'wa innallaha ‘ala nasrihim laqadir' – whoever God permits to wage Jihad, He will also make victorious, because He has the power. If this condition is fulfilled somewhere, you have the right to count it as Jihad by all means, whether it is Jihad or not – the basis for calling it Jihad is there. If it does not apply, how can you call it Jihad? A Palestinian came to me in great agitation and said: we have heard you say this and that; tell me, is the Jihad of Palestine, of the liberation of Palestine, Jihad or not? I said: according to the Holy Qur’an it is not. He was very worked up and said: how is it not? I said: do you know where the Holy Qur’an permitted Jihad? It is the verse of Sura Al-Hajj, is it not? Alongside, He said: I give permission with this condition and this promise: God, seeing you weak, promises you that He will certainly give you victory, and He has power to do so. I said: on how many fronts have you defeated the Jews? Tell me! Does God lie? He threw you into Jihad and withdrew His hand at the time of help – is that decency? If a human did such a thing you would turn your face from him. How do you worship a God who tells you once: fight, fight, don't worry, I am behind you – and when the beating comes, you look behind and there is no one. I said: this is the same God who made the promise to the Messenger of Allah (saw) and proved true every time, turned every state of weakness into dominance. When his servants clashed with Rome they triumphed over it too; when they clashed with the power of Chosroes and Caesar, it was seen that the true Promiser was behind them. Where did He go in your case? So if that was Jihad, this is not; and if that was God, then your God is not the same. Understood? So the Holy Qur’an has given a definition of Jihad whose fulfilment can be seen.

10 of 10 left today