25. What is the difference between law-bearing (shar‘i) prophethood and zilli (shadow) prophethood?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 18 December 1991

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: What is the difference between law-bearing (shar‘i) prophethood and zilli (shadow) prophethood?

The comparison is between law-bearing and non-law-bearing prophethood, not with zilli; zilli has a different meaning. Law-bearing prophethood means a prophet upon whom God Almighty has issued commandments and prohibitions, that is, such injunctions as did not exist before in the law he followed, so that this law is being changed. But if the commandments and prohibitions are in accordance with the very law he acts upon, it will not be called law. For example, if someone receives the revelation ‘Rise and offer the prayer’, you cannot call it law, because his faith already rests on a law in which this revelation exists. It would be called law if someone received the revelation ‘Do not offer the prayer.’ Therefore those who accuse Hazrat Masih-e-Mau‘ud (as) of claiming to be a law-bearing prophet speak foolishly. If they proved that the Masih-e-Mau‘ud (as) received a revelation that abrogated even the smallest detail of the law of the Holy Qur’an, then the accusation would be correct. If they say that the same verses were revealed to him which are in the Holy Qur’an and relate to the law, the answer is that he already believed in them; it was a confirmation, not an opposition. So he remained non-law-bearing despite this. Have you understood? If you asked the question from this angle, the answer has been given.

10 of 10 left today