26. What I actually mean is: how many kinds of prophethood are there? There is zilli prophethood.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 18 December 1991

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: What I actually mean is: how many kinds of prophethood are there? There is zilli prophethood.

Look, however many kinds of prophethood there may be, that is not the point. What is the basic definition of prophethood? If you understand that, why should we get into the debate about how many kinds there are; this topic creates a lot of confusion. The basic condition is that Allah the Exalted Himself appoints someone and tells him: ‘Speak to people as My representative’, and makes believing in him obligatory. This is the basic condition of prophethood, which you will find present in every kind; where it is absent, it is not prophethood. Have you understood? For now, keep Hazrat Masih-e-Mau‘ud (as) aside in your mind. Ask non-Ahmadi mullahs: Will God Himself appoint the Imam Mahdi, will he be elected by votes, or will he claim the imamate out of his own desire? What will their answer be? Necessarily, that God Almighty Himself will make the Imam Mahdi the Imam and tell him: ‘I make you Imam’; without this no one can become Imam Mahdi. The next question is: Having made him Imam Himself, will He then permit people to accept him or not as they wish? The only possible answer is: Certainly not. Who is anyone to deny the one whom God makes Imam? Now ask them: Where the Holy Qur’an mentions the articles of faith, that believing in these things is necessary, various kinds are mentioned, and one kind has been chosen from each. Believing in Allah is necessary, right? Allah has no one of His kind; Allah is One. Believing in the angels is necessary; they are a kind of their own, separate from God. Believing in the Books is necessary; they are a kind of their own, neither angels nor God. Believing in the Messengers is necessary; they are a kind of their own. And belief in the Hereafter is necessary, right? Among human beings, in whom was belief declared necessary – the Messengers, or non-Messengers too? Belief in none besides them is necessary. Subhan Allah, what a point! Tell the mullah: Show where it is written that belief in non-Messengers is necessary; prove it from the Holy Qur’an and Hadith. And you declare belief in the Imam Mahdi necessary – then why do you not accept him as a prophet? Both conditions are fulfilled: God Himself appointed him and made belief in him obligatory. And the Holy Qur’an says that among human beings belief is necessary only in the prophets, not in others. Don’t accept it, certainly, don’t accept it, it makes no difference to me. So in practice our belief is the same. The non-Ahmadi mullah has the same belief as ours; he just does not give it the name. They say the same thing but shy away from the name. This was the last question, so after it I will tell the anecdote I used to mention in Pakistan when answering the mullahs’ questions, which livens up the gathering a little – to make clear that our belief is the same and only the name differs. We are truthful: the belief we hold, we have the courage to state, and we call it by the name it should have. The person in whom these two conditions are found – that God Himself raised him and declared belief in him necessary – cannot be anything but a prophet. Not a single exception is found to this general rule. This must be common between us and them. Now they believe about the Imam Mahdi that God made him and belief in him is necessary; we believe the same. The necessary conclusion is that he is a prophet. This they do not accept; they are afraid to say it. The definition of a prophet applies, but they are afraid to say it. The definition of man is ‘rational animal’; they accept this, they call a human a rational animal, but are afraid to call him human. The following example fits them: There was a king who loved a horse very much. It became very ill, and he announced: ‘Whatever wretch brings me the news that this horse has died, I will kill him.’ They were in great difficulty. When all were helpless and the horse finally died, they devised a scheme: Catch some passing traveller and have him go and inform the king. So they caught a man – like those sitting before us – very simple in appearance but very shrewd inside. He said: ‘Why me? Go yourselves…’ They said: ‘No, you only have to decide whether to die at our hands or the king’s. If you go, you will die at the king’s hands; if not, at ours. Choose the death you consider better.’ He said: ‘At the king’s hands is better’, and went. He said: ‘Your Majesty, congratulations! I bring very, very great good news.’ The king asked: ‘What good news?’ He said: ‘Your horse was ill, wasn’t it? Its writhing could be heard for miles, the earth shook, it was in such pain. Now I went close – not a sound even there, it is very calm. Its heartbeat was so strong it sounded like drums beating; I put my ear to it – no sound. Its breathing was so alarming, as if saws were running, and now it doesn’t come at all. It has become so peaceful.’ The king said: ‘You wretch, why don’t you say it has died?’ He said: ‘Your Majesty, You are saying it, not I – how would I dare?’ So they have left the task of speaking the truth to us: what we say, they say ‘Your Majesty says it, we don’t’ – but the definition is the same as ours; there is no difference in it.

10 of 10 left today