2. My second question: We say that if someone enters the Khilafat of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat, takes Bai’at at the hand of the Khalifa of the time and then becomes an apostate, we call him an apostate. Why then are those who did not take Bai’at at the hand of the [fourth] Khalifa of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw), Hazrat Ali (ra), but even fought against him, not called apostates?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 24 December 1991

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: My second question: We say that if someone enters the Khilafat of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat, takes Bai’at at the hand of the Khalifa of the time and then becomes an apostate, we call him an apostate. Why then are those who did not take Bai’at at the hand of the [fourth] Khalifa of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw), Hazrat Ali (ra), but even fought against him, not called apostates?

Because an apostate is one who himself severs his connection with religion and with the Bai’at. Do you understand? As for the people who became [involved in conflict] in the time of Hazrat Uthman and Hazrat Ali (ra): if you read their history, the picture is not one-sided; some read it this way, others that way, both sides have certain arguments. Allah will judge every person according to the state of his heart and the capacity of his mind. And we have no knowledge of the state of hearts, nor of the powers of the mind, nor of intentions. So when you see two parties fighting, and this happened fourteen hundred years before you, with a dark age in between, narrations being formed and various other, even alien, things mixed in – who gave you the right to sit as their judge? You neither have the means of judgement, nor has God appointed you as their judge. They have already appeared in the court of the One who is their Judge. Therefore it is absurd to talk like this: how can someone judge who has not been appointed judge for this task, who does not have all the evidence, and whom the Holy Qur’an has advised not to reach a conclusion until there is evidence? Therefore one should exercise restraint in such a case. In the Holy Qur’an Allah says that those people preceded in faith, and those who come after them send peace upon them and pray: ‘Rabbana la taj’al fi qulubina ghillan lilladhina amanu’ – ‘O our Lord, let no rancour arise in our hearts against them.’ I remember that in the presence of Hazrat Imam Baqir – probably it was him, I may be mistaken about the name, but I remember it was Imam Baqir – someone spoke insolently about those Companions who did not agree with Hazrat Ali, or about the Khalifas who came before him. He stood up in great wrath, recited this verse and said: See, this verse bears witness against you. Regarding those who preceded you in faith, you are commanded to pray: O God, let no rancour, malice or hatred arise in our hearts for them. And you sit here, thirteen hundred years or more later, asking how we should judge them. You have not been appointed to judge at all. Exercise restraint and take this position: Allah knows best. As for us: they believed before us, they made sacrifices in faith; if anyone erred, may Allah forgive him. We have no right to judge beyond that.

10 of 10 left today