7. Second question: There is a Hadith of the Holy Prophet (saw) that my Ummah will split into 73 sects; 72 will go to hell, one to paradise. What is meant by the sect that goes to paradise? [Huzoor: He said ‘Jamaat’, do not alter the Hadith.] All right, one Jamaat. We say we are that Jamaat. But in our Jamaat there are some people whose deeds appear such that they do not deserve paradise.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 24 December 1991

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Second question: There is a Hadith of the Holy Prophet (saw) that my Ummah will split into 73 sects; 72 will go to hell, one to paradise. What is meant by the sect that goes to paradise? [Huzoor: He said ‘Jamaat’, do not alter the Hadith.] All right, one Jamaat. We say we are that Jamaat. But in our Jamaat there are some people whose deeds appear such that they do not deserve paradise.

[On laughter in the audience:] They are laughing because in no time he has become a judge as well; he is progressing very fast. First he judged others, now he has made himself judge and passed verdicts on deeds: this one goes to hell, that one does not. Who gave you this authority? (Huzoor, non-Ahmadis ask this question.) No, listen: you yourself are asking like a non-Ahmadi. The point is that you draw a wrong inference from a statement and apply it wholesale. This is wrong in both directions. To say – God forbid – that every single non-Ahmadi of the Ummah of Muhammad is hellbound is completely false; not every non-Ahmadi is meant. The general ‘in the fire’ means that all these sects are sects of the fire, but it is not necessary that every single person in these sects goes to the fire. ‘In the fire’ is an expression of displeasure because of their divisions and errors, merely an expression of displeasure. Otherwise the Holy Qur’an states that even among Jews and Christians people can go to paradise. Should – God forbid – the calamity befall the Ummah of Muhammad that all sects completely, with every single person, become hellbound? Fear God! If there are exceptions among them, why can there be no exceptions in the paradise sect? Whoever belongs to the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat is not guaranteed paradise. The one sect of paradise means that their thinking, their thoughts and their beliefs are righteous. There is a hidden condition in this, which reason grasps: provided that these people also do good deeds and act upon what they believe. Under this condition Ahmadis become people of paradise, and under the same condition others will be hellbound: those who make mischief in opposition to the Imam of the age, their leaders, whose deeds are in God’s sight. And even among them, Allah will never seize those who fell victim to misunderstanding. So do not make such big claims that disfigure the image of Ahmadiyyat before people. (Remark from the audience: He asked whether in your Jamaat there are also some who apparently …) Yes, apparently – then it is apparently. Use a little sense. You studied with us in Waqf-e-Jadid [teachers’ class], I also taught you. You also know the Hadith that on the Day of Judgement the Messenger of Allah (saw) will see some of his Companions, who were with him, being led towards hell. Have you heard it or not? (Yes, in Bukhari.) Now tell me: if even among those people of paradise about whom the verdict is that there never was a better group of people of paradise – ‘Thullatun minal awwalin’, whereas for the later ones the word ‘Thulla’ was not used; that was a large group, ‘Thullatun minal awwalin’, among the later ones there are comparatively fewer people of that rank – there were nevertheless such people, then these conditions are implicitly included, they are hidden. (This was an important error of mine which I now understand.) How many times have you debated people to defeat them? (Not to defeat …) I know you, you have the habit of making quips; enough. Try to win hearts as well.

10 of 10 left today