15. Assalamu alaikum. My name is Abdul Wadud. I belong to the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat Soro in Odisha. My question is: when our non-Ahmadi brothers there face some hardship or have some need, for example when their children sit an exam to pass their education, they go to their Pir and say: “When our child passes, we will lay a sheet at the Pir’s shrine.” Or if someone falls ill or has an accident, they lay sheets on graves. They make a vow to the Baba: when he recovers, we will lay a sheet on the Baba’s grave. (Hazrat Mirza Tahir Ahmad (rh): All right, so what is your question?) My question: when someone then recovers or the child passes – this practice is obviously completely wrong, it is polytheistic; it is God who does it, yet they keep clothing the Pir with sheets. And then – does the grave feel cold that they cover it with cloth?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 24 December 1991

AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense

Question: Assalamu alaikum. My name is Abdul Wadud. I belong to the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat Soro in Odisha. My question is: when our non-Ahmadi brothers there face some hardship or have some need, for example when their children sit an exam to pass their education, they go to their Pir and say: “When our child passes, we will lay a sheet at the Pir’s shrine.” Or if someone falls ill or has an accident, they lay sheets on graves. They make a vow to the Baba: when he recovers, we will lay a sheet on the Baba’s grave. (Hazrat Mirza Tahir Ahmad (rh): All right, so what is your question?) My question: when someone then recovers or the child passes – this practice is obviously completely wrong, it is polytheistic; it is God who does it, yet they keep clothing the Pir with sheets. And then – does the grave feel cold that they cover it with cloth?

No. That is a separate matter. A poet from Pakistan once said a couplet: someone should tell those who lay sheets on graves that the poor people shivering in the cold have a greater right to be clothed with a sheet than to have sheets laid on shrines. Understood? So in this respect too it is absurd, and it is also shirk (associating partners with God). Such things should be rejected; they are not good things. Understood? Why do they not ask God, why do they ask the Pir?
(Questioner: They say that when one has to go to a senior officer, one first has to get permission from the peon, and only then can one go to the officer. Therefore they say that if we first present our request to the Pir, the Pir will pray for us, and then, after the Pir, God will listen to us. That is their belief.)
But this is not correct. They have made up a false analogy. If a Deputy Commissioner has a decision to make, the most that happens is that one slips the peon a little money and then reaches him. But he will not show any regard for the peon; he will make the decision himself. Likewise, it is God Himself who decides. And when God has freed you from peons and says: “inni qarib, ujibu da‘watad-da‘i idha da‘an” – there is no other intermediary: I am near you; when the caller calls Me, I answer him – then who would be so foolish as to run after peons? If God’s court were an ignorant court like those of the world, there would be something to it. But Allah says: I need no intermediary for you to reach Me; pray, I am standing right beside you. Now tell me, what need is there for them?
(Questioner: When you tell them, they say: roughly speaking, listen – when one has to go to a senior officer, one first has to approach the peon …)
They have told you themselves: on the way to an officer guards are posted; on the way to God none are posted. Do you understand? Allah says: My relationship with every single person is direct. Please sit down.

10 of 10 left today