9. There is a boy in my class who says there is no Allah. I say there is. He demands proof. What should I tell him?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 29 May 1993
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: There is a boy in my class who says there is no Allah. I say there is. He demands proof. What should I tell him?
Ask him whether he himself exists. He does; he has eyes, ears, a nose, a brain – very complicated things – a kidney system, a heart system, intestines and the whole digestive system. Ask him: did you make this yourself? If not, who did? He will say: no, I was earlier a relatively stupid animal and then I became human. Then the question arises: did that stupid animal, which could not make itself, make you? How did so much progress come about? Someone from outside is making it. Do you understand? If he says it happened through evolution, called Irtiqa, the easy answer is: is an aeroplane complicated or not? With how many parts, how much racking of brains and effort people designed it and developed it after experiments. Tell him: I don’t believe anyone made the aeroplane, prove it. If the whole world vanished and an aeroplane turned up in a later age and a debate began – one says someone made it, another says no – the one who denies could say it made itself, gradually progressing: first the wheel, then the cart, then gradually the horse carriage, then through progress motorcars, then gradually aeroplanes, and finally jumbo jets. If someone said so, would you accept that it happened like this? Would you not reject it if someone said the aeroplane made itself? So whoever claims it made itself must prove it, not you. You will necessarily say that so complicated a thing was made by a maker who has a mind. The mind comes first, the thing afterwards. Something with no mind cannot develop itself and make its own mind. Do you understand? Therefore man is a complete machine, he has a brain and very complicated machinery; such a brain cannot come about without one who has a mind. To make a computer, the mind comes first and the computer afterwards. Right? So when it is debated whether the world came first or the mind, one must accept the mind came first. By mind is meant the power to think. So whatever exists from the beginning is a thinking entity, not lifeless, and because it is first, it has the capacity to create things. Remove it, and how did thoughtless things become highly thinking ones by themselves? That cannot be. Understood?