10. We don’t celebrate birthdays. My German friends celebrate birthdays and invite me. Can I go or not?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 29 May 1993

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: We don’t celebrate birthdays. My German friends celebrate birthdays and invite me. Can I go or not?

There is no harm as such in going to a birthday. But in Ahmadi culture birthdays are not celebrated. So you should tell them: if I come to you, I won’t invite you to my birthday because I don’t celebrate it; this would be one-sided only. Then you will feel awkward, won’t you? They invite you, you cannot invite them. Therefore it is better, when the favour is one-sided, to avoid such a situation and not keep relations in which you cannot reciprocate. So explain to them and tell them why we don’t celebrate: we are religious people and greatly respect religious leaders, and to our knowledge no religious leader celebrated a birthday – neither Jesus (as), nor Moses (as), nor Hazrat Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), nor the Promised Messiah (as). If it were so important, why wouldn’t they have done so? When great people, whose birth was so significant that it affected hundreds of millions, do not have that day celebrated, what about us? We are ordinary people; what difference did our birth make to the world? Why should we celebrate needlessly? Do you understand the argument? Explain it to them like this: these are pointless customs, we do not follow them.

10 of 10 left today