23. Hudhur, my name is Masood, and my father's name is Mirza Mubarak Ahmad. My question is: will animals go to Paradise?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 29 May 1993

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Hudhur, my name is Masood, and my father's name is Mirza Mubarak Ahmad. My question is: will animals go to Paradise?

Animals apparently cannot go to Paradise, because as far as we know there is no Shariah for animals. Paradise is for people who could do evil but do not, who could do good and do good; Paradise is for them. The life of animals is controlled genetically. Therefore for them there is neither punishment nor reward. If they kill one another, tear apart and eat, they receive no punishment. And there is no virtue at all for them, because they act according to the habits that come to them by nature. So there is no reason for there to be Paradise for them. Secondly, as far as the Holy Qur’an is concerned, in the concept of Paradise presented by the Holy Qur’an no animals are seen, except for one thing: the meat of birds is mentioned. So the question arises whether that will be real meat and whether birds will also be raised in Paradise or not. I think these are matters in a spiritual sense; real birds are not meant. And the Holy Qur’an shows that we have not seen this Paradise; no eye has seen it, nor ear heard. They are things of another kind which we cannot understand. Therefore, to conclude from the mention of birds that there will be animals in Paradise is not correct. Did you understand?

10 of 10 left today