2. Huzur, in the city where I live there are many Turks, and they have three or four mosques there. In these mosques they talk more about politics than about the worship of God. Whenever we hold Tabligh conversations with them, they turn the topic to politics. I want to know what the relationship between religion and politics is, and what the Holy Qur’an and Sunnah teach about it.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 10 September 1993

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Huzur, in the city where I live there are many Turks, and they have three or four mosques there. In these mosques they talk more about politics than about the worship of God. Whenever we hold Tabligh conversations with them, they turn the topic to politics. I want to know what the relationship between religion and politics is, and what the Holy Qur’an and Sunnah teach about it.

The Holy Qur’an clearly says: “The mosques belong to Allah, so do not call upon anyone besides Allah” – i.e. mosques are built solely for the remembrance of Allah; do not talk about anyone other than God in the mosque. The word is “tad‘u”: do not call upon anyone else. But politics too is included in this, in the sense that these people have made political idols besides God. They hide political objectives under the cloak of religion and try to attain them in the mosque, which is causing great harm to the Muslim world. For governments, to protect their politics, then impose restrictions on mosques, send spies there, and clashes occur between them and the mullahs, not only outside but inside the mosques as well. Therefore this is extremely improper, shameful and impermissible. In mosques nothing other than the remembrance of Allah or religious matters is permissible. They base it on the argument that the Holy Prophet (saw) himself governed, so a religious leader himself has the right to politics. These are all excuses of the ego. The Holy Prophet (saw) never made the mosque a seat of government. He used the mosque for the remembrance of Allah and for consultations with delegations that came from outside. It is not unlikely that he also spoke about jihad while sitting in the mosque. The questions visitors asked were for religious knowledge; sometimes they may have strayed somewhat from religion. But the Holy Prophet (saw) never made mosques a centre of politics. On the contrary, the one mosque that was made a centre of politics, Masjid-e-Dirar, was demolished by Allah’s command. That example suffices: if you make mosques centres of politics, then in God’s sight those mosques will become empty of God’s remembrance and will not be worthy for God’s righteous servants to pray in.
[Questioner: Does a religious leader have the right to take part in politics?] Why are you now asking further questions back and forth? I have answered what you asked about the Turks’ mosques. What does this second question have to do with that? What is troubling you? Say it openly. [Questioner: They say that they themselves have entered politics as religious leaders.] A religious leader has the right to take part in politics in his individual capacity, why not? After all, he also exists as a citizen, and as a citizen he can exercise his personal right in politics. As a leader he can tell his people what clean politics is from the Islamic point of view and which things are beneficial for them. There is no objection to that. But a religious leader making [the mosque] a centre of politics is another matter. Do you understand?

10 of 10 left today