8. I have been here since 1987. My question is about the Jehovah’s Witnesses, an offshoot of Christianity. They have many wrong customs. We talk with them a lot in the course of Tabligh, but when it comes to reading, or a video or something like that, [they do not accept it].

Urdu question-and-answer session, 10 September 1993

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: I have been here since 1987. My question is about the Jehovah’s Witnesses, an offshoot of Christianity. They have many wrong customs. We talk with them a lot in the course of Tabligh, but when it comes to reading, or a video or something like that, [they do not accept it].

The Jehovah’s Witnesses are very active preachers of Christianity, but behind them there is also a political web. They had become very active in Africa, and some governments there stopped them from working on the grounds that, according to them, they had evidence that they are in fact part of the American espionage system – and they were stopped in countries where the head of state himself was a Christian. Therefore there are mysterious things about these people about which we cannot yet say with certainty what their purpose is, why they are doing it, where their money comes from, who supports them. But let me tell you one thing: these people are very clever and very stubborn. An ordinary Ahmadi who does not understand their tricks can hardly cope with them. So in England, when they began knocking on the doors of Ahmadi homes, some of our children did not know what to answer. I taught them one or two things, and wherever they used them, by the grace of Allah these people fled completely speechless. I told them: before they attack you, you attack them and ask them certain specific questions. I will put before you one question in detail, which I learned from the Holy Qur’an. Allah says in the Holy Qur’an: “How can He have a son when He has no consort?” – How can God have a son when He has no wife? So I told them: ask them whether Hazrat Mary was God’s wife or not. If she was His wife, did God perform a marriage with her, did she become His proper wife? What will they answer? If she was not His wife, then the son who was born is illegitimate. If she was His wife – their own belief is that there is no divorce in Christianity, and it is not established that Hazrat Mary obtained a divorce from God – then she married a second time. So she had two husbands at the same time: God as husband in His place, and the second husband became Joseph. They laugh at the four wives of Islam – why do they not laugh at the two husbands of the Messiah’s mother? Those who asked this told me that they turned pale and could not come up with any answer. They said, no, first prove … If the Messiah is God’s son, then it is necessary that God has a wife. And this is exactly the point the Holy Qur’an has taught. When you corner them, they themselves will have to admit that God has no wife. If He has no wife and a son was born [of Him], he is not a legitimate son; and a wife is necessary for a son. There were some other such questions too. When they came to me – at first they came once or twice – and I asked these questions, after that they never showed their faces again. Ahmadis too, instead of reacting defensively, should first take the offensive against these people. The beliefs of Islam are so definitive, so powerful, so reasonable that the present fabric of Christianity which they themselves made – the Christianity revealed to the Messiah was monotheistic, believing in the One God; the Christianity they have now made is hocus-pocus, there is no substance in it. When you attack them from a rational point of view, the ground slips from beneath their feet. So adopt this line against the Jehovah’s Witnesses. Besides this, I’ll tell you one more thing: in Spain, on my last tour, in two gatherings I criticised Christianity from a purely rational point of view. After returning, when I had it transcribed, I found there were still many gaps in it. So I dictated the same speech again with further additions. It is now in its final form as a book – it is almost ready – waiting to be printed. When it is printed, have the Jehovah’s Witnesses read it and see what they answer. They will have no answer, I am telling you already. So wait for it to be translated into German; then it can deliberately be given to the Jehovah’s Witnesses with the challenge: first bring answers to these points, then talk to us further. Understood?
[Questioner: Huzur, they do become speechless, but they don’t budge; when it comes to the end, they are not willing to listen. What is the strategy for this?] I have already answered that first: these people are not necessarily sincere in religion. It may be, as some suspect and some governments have decided, that they are merely a web of an intelligence agency. In that case they will neither listen attentively to your reasonable arguments nor be willing to accept them. So butting heads with such people is a waste of time. But if you simply drop the matter, they will say you ran away. I say: end the matter in such a way that it is they who give up and they who run. This is my answer to you.

10 of 10 left today