26. The second question is: if magic exists, can one human being harm another through magic?
Urdu question-and-answer session, May 1994
AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense
Question: The second question is: if magic exists, can one human being harm another through magic?
If magic exists, then it is a power. Every power, if wrongly used, can harm a person, to the extent of that power and to the extent it is misused. A thief too has power, a robber has power, a person of bad character has power; these people certainly have power too, and one sees how much harm they cause – but not in comparison with God. For when God decides that this power shall fail and sends a Messenger, then despite their might they are brought to nothing. As for magic, it is a controversial matter; it is necessary to understand magic. But whatever it is, magic is a power, and the misuse of this power can cause harm, there is no doubt about that. In fact, magic is the spiritual, mental power of man which he uses. If he uses it for good purposes, there will be benefit; if he uses it for bad purposes, there will be evil. In the time of Hazrat Moses (as), the magicians of Pharaoh wanted to use it for evil and deceive people. Allah, the Exalted, says: “They bewitched the eyes of the people.” They bewitched people's eyes; thereupon in their imagination the ropes appeared as snakes, but not in reality. Understood? In this is also the other answer to your question: when a person uses his magic, that is, the mental power by which he can captivate others' sight and deceive them, for evil, and the power of Allah then confronts it, it undoes it and destroys its effect. When Moses threw down his staff, their magic was broken; the ropes were not snakes, rather what they had conjured before the eyes vanished, and suddenly the snakes became ropes again. That is the answer: when the divine power confronts another power, the magic comes to nothing. … Nowadays it often happens that people out of ignorance believe in (magic), believe in trickery, and some fall into such states that they think someone has bewitched them. Thus belief in magic has spread widely, also in Europe, and many people in India and Pakistan have fallen prey to this superstition of magic and sorcery. For example, people there say: we are at a loss, in our houses splashes suddenly appear, things catch fire by themselves – surely someone has bewitched us. When I wrote (about this) to Nazir sahib Islah-o-Irshad and there were many such incidents that were thoroughly investigated, each time it was proven that someone from the household or from the neighbourhood was behind it, or (the so-called healer) who went to drive out the jinn had himself staged something to make an impression. In such cases Huzur establishes what really lies behind the magic. Nevertheless the power (of the mind) as such is recognised; in the world of hypnosis it is recognised, and its misuse can cause harm. Hazrat Masih-e-Maud (as) once, before his claim, when Allah had not yet appointed him as the Messiah, went to meet Sufi Ahmad Jan sahib, whose piety, righteousness and Sufism were widely renowned. He asked him: you perform a great deal of worship and many exercises – what have you attained? Tell me. He (himself) answered: there in front of the mosque is a bazaar; if I direct my attention at a man walking there, he immediately falls to the ground and writhes. (He considered this a miracle.) Hazrat Masih-e-Maud (as) said: what benefit is that to mankind? (You do no good with it.) Then he immediately repented, sought forgiveness, and understood that this is that servant of Allah who is to become the Imam of this age. That is: use (spiritual powers) for good, for goodness. He composed this verse: “We sick ones look to you; be the Messiah for God's sake.” Hazrat Masih-e-Maud (as) had not yet made this claim at that time, but he recognised him, … and he instructed his descendants: when he makes the claim, (accept him). Some of his descendants were lost, but many entered the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. Among them are well-known names in the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat such as Siraj-ud-Din sahib and … sahib.