2. My name is Auran (?). My question: some prayers, like Fajr, have few rak‘at, while Isha has more. Is there a reason for this?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 27 May 1994
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: My name is Auran (?). My question: some prayers, like Fajr, have few rak‘at, while Isha has more. Is there a reason for this?
According to different times of day, a person's occupations change, and accordingly Allah has made the rak‘at more or fewer. The most rak‘at are not only in Isha but also in Zuhr and Asr – all have four each. The morning prayer has two; among the obligatory prayers only the morning prayer has two. But before it people have already offered the eleven rak‘at of Tahajjud, some a little fewer, some a little more. Therefore, by the time one reaches the morning prayer, the day begins; people have to go to work, have other occupations, the farmer has to plough. So before dawn a large part of the prayer has already been offered, hence two rak‘at suffice in the morning. At Isha, after finishing dinner, you sit comfortably at home. Now the question why Zuhr has more: Zuhr is midday, what is called lunchtime. It has something in common with Isha: one is dinner time and the other lunch time. So Allah has placed a spiritual lunch and a spiritual dinner in both times – not only are the rak‘at more, but the associated Sunnah or Witr are also more. All of this we are saying by estimation; no specific reason has been stated by Allah Himself. On your question I thought this could be the reason. If anyone thinks of another reason which is valid, that may also be true. Understood?