7. My name is Masroor Ahmad. Praying five times a day is obligatory, right? Then why do we pray three Witr? Are the three Witr also obligatory like the five prayers? … In my books it is written that in Isha one prays four, three, two … four, two and finally three Witr – why does one pray these three Witr?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 27 May 1994
AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense
Question: My name is Masroor Ahmad. Praying five times a day is obligatory, right? Then why do we pray three Witr? Are the three Witr also obligatory like the five prayers? … In my books it is written that in Isha one prays four, three, two … four, two and finally three Witr – why does one pray these three Witr?
Witr can also be prayed after Tahajjud, hence the objection? What is this – you asked without thinking. You had no objection to the Sunnah, so why to the Witr? Explain some logic to me, then I'll answer. [Aside about the cap: is that your own cap? – No, it belongs to someone else. – He is thinking with the brain of the one whose cap he borrowed. Listen carefully.] I am explaining to you: with the obligatory prayers there are Sunnah attached and also Witr; therefore this objection is a wrong way of asking. Besides the obligatory there are other things which beautify and protect it. You have a body; basically everyone has the same skeleton, but with it come colour, blood, complexion, big or small eyes and many other things with which man has been adorned. Even without them man would exist, but by adding these small things beauty has been created. If – God forbid – your eyelashes and eyebrows fell out, how would you look? Not good, although you would be complete; brain, appearance, everything would remain the same, only a little hair would fall out. And those who go bald – in old age it is normal, but those who go bald in youth walk around wearing a cap all the time. What difference does it make if a little hair is less? But it doesn't look good. A young girl who has had no hair since childhood and is bald – how much she suffers. So some things are not obligatory – these examples are of things that are not obligatory – yet they play a role, create beauty and have many benefits. So in the prayer system God has made, a central part is obligatory, with it are Sunnah, Witr and Nawafil; these three become flesh, skin, heart and hair upon it and make the whole prayer system beautiful. That is one thing. Secondly it is called Witr because after two rak‘at a third is prayed, and all obligatory rak‘at are two or four. … But I will speak about Witr later. First look at Maghrib: how many rak‘at does it have, and how many do the others have? Two or four. All five prayers except Maghrib have two or four rak‘at, none three, none one. The Maghrib prayer makes the obligatory prayers witr (odd). Witr means a number not divisible by two: one, three, five, seven, nine are witr. Allah is One, so He loves the odd; in His worship too He has preferred the odd, a number not divisible by two. The Maghrib prayer makes all obligatory prayers odd: when that one is added, the total is not divisible by two. Look: Zuhr, Asr, Isha – four each, twelve rak‘at; two in the morning – fourteen; and three of Maghrib – seventeen. Seventeen is not divisible by two; it made all obligatory prayers odd. In the world of Nawafil running separately alongside – Sunnah and Nafl – the Witr you pray after Isha make the Sunnah and Nawafil odd; their number does not remain even. This is the wisdom. I am explaining: like the obligatory, the non-obligatory prayers have divisions, some are called Sunnah, some Nawafil; their rak‘at also run in twos and fours. But when you pray Witr at the end, it does not make the obligatory odd but the Nawafil and Sunnah; so their rak‘at also become odd, just as the obligatory rak‘at become odd. Have you understood now?