9. My name is Mashhood Ahmad. My question: when we pray Zuhr and Asr, why do we not recite aloud in them?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 27 May 1994

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: My name is Mashhood Ahmad. My question: when we pray Zuhr and Asr, why do we not recite aloud in them?

Yes. I have explained this several times before: God has placed certain natural requirements in human nature, and accordingly this is how it should be. Look, in the morning birds chirp and go about singing; and when the sun is about to set, around dusk when it grows darker, the birds again chirp loudly. In the middle of the day there is silence – is there or not? Why? It is the demand of nature. At night again there are gatherings of song and liveliness. In the morning when shepherds go out, they also sing; camel drivers sing aloud as they drive their camels, and at midday they fall silent. So Allah too, according to the demands of human nature, has placed loud melodious recitation in some prayers and silence in others. Understood? And the Adhan is called at all five times – why? You cannot call the Adhan silently, because you have to call. If birds call at midday too, they call aloud. Can you ever call silently? Adhan is a call, meaning to summon; how will you summon without speaking? Call them to you without making a sound – can you? No. That is why there is a necessity in the Adhan. In old times there was no clock time; even now not every country has it. You have got clocks, you know the time; but Islam is for every age and every country, and not everywhere are there these clocks. Understood? (Is there more to discuss or is it enough? – It is enough.)

10 of 10 left today