11. (Question not preserved; apparently: if everything was created, who created Allah?)
Urdu question-and-answer session, 27 May 1994
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: (Question not preserved; apparently: if everything was created, who created Allah?)
People raise this question about Allah; it is not something to laugh at. The question is: if everything was made by someone, then the question will remain forever and has no answer – everything was made by someone, who made the one who made it, and then who made him? That is the question, isn't it? But we do not say that everything was made by someone; nobody says that. It is impossible that everything was made by someone. There is certainly one thing that has always existed, otherwise nothing could have been made either. Since things exist, the question arises: can something have always existed, or must someone necessarily have made it? The answer is: no – if everything must have been made by someone, then who made the one who made it? Therefore that answer is wrong. Understood? The correct answer is that something necessarily has always existed; without this, reason cannot accept anything. What is it that has always existed – God, or we, or this matter? When we compare, we find that this world we see is itself changing; it bears signs that someone made it; therefore it has not always existed. If it has not always existed, then someone else must have always existed – that is God. Understood? Present the matter to others in this way: that He has always existed.