2. (Asghar Mughal:) Assalamu alaikum. You have spoken in considerable detail. My only question is: you are a Muslim, I am a Muslim, all these people sitting here are Muslims, alhamdulillah, they recite the Kalima. Fine. So what yardstick do we have by which, about a person who recites the Kalima, I or someone else or a third person may say that he is a kafir? And if someone has such a yardstick, what is its basis? Is it political, or is it simply a matter of inventing some catchword to humiliate the other? If so, then it is wrong. If not, then why does it happen? Respectfully.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 20 May 1995

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: (Asghar Mughal:) Assalamu alaikum. You have spoken in considerable detail. My only question is: you are a Muslim, I am a Muslim, all these people sitting here are Muslims, alhamdulillah, they recite the Kalima. Fine. So what yardstick do we have by which, about a person who recites the Kalima, I or someone else or a third person may say that he is a kafir? And if someone has such a yardstick, what is its basis? Is it political, or is it simply a matter of inventing some catchword to humiliate the other? If so, then it is wrong. If not, then why does it happen? Respectfully.

This question is very fundamental, JazakAllah. But let me make one thing clear: someone calling another a kafir makes no practical difference. If someone considers another a kafir, let him go on considering it. The question is whether he issues a fatwa against the communal unity of the Ummah of Muhammad and, as a consequence of his fatwa of kufr, declares it necessary that the other part be cut off from the community and thrown out. That is the root of strife. And a solution for it – the solution is the one which the Messenger of Allah (saw) has already presented. The example I just gave of the seventy-two sects is very clear. Before that too there were differences in the community of Moses, but ordinary prophets kept coming, scholars of the Mujaddid type, prophets kept coming, but there was no Messiahship. After all, what is the difference between a prophet and the Messiah?

(Questioner:) I am asking you about the fundamental point. I understand that one can go into detail, I understand, but in short: when its basis is wrong, why should people not know about it in detail? Who will say it?

(Hudur:) That is exactly what I want.

(Questioner:) I say expressly that no one can say it. But this malaise, that we as Muslims among ourselves …

(Hudur:) When I try to explain the solution, you do not listen.

(Questioner:) One second, I will try to listen to you. So, by levelling such an accusation, it makes no difference to the other; but the one who accuses knows that these people are wrong, that either they are mushrik or they are making some such false statement whose basis is wrong. So the one accused does have a right, but why do the two parties not understand it between themselves?

(Hudur:) That is exactly what I am trying to explain. They do not understand because religious leaders are not established on Taqwa. If the religious leadership were established on Taqwa, this situation could not arise. And that is why the Holy Prophet (saw) compared this era of the Ummah to that condition of the Jews which had reached its end, after which it seemed there was no longer any cure. At that time his method of treatment is that Allah then takes the matter into His own hands. Until a Divine Reformer comes, these people cannot be set right. The reason is – you also mentioned politics – that politics has entered religion, and instead of the fear of God, decisions are made on the basis of whether any danger threatens our human territory. The question of God’s territory has vanished. When these signs appear, then be certain that the leaders are no longer worthy of being followed.

I give an example. If a Shia becomes a Sunni, there is an uproar, and if in a Shia environment someone becomes a Sunni, all hell breaks loose. But if a Shia stops practising Islam, there is no uproar at all. If a Sunni becomes a Shia, all hell breaks loose, the ulema issue fatwas and say: whoever did this, we will kill him, we will take revenge, and we will burn their – what are they called – the ta‘ziyas they carry in procession, and so on. But before the eyes of the ulema, their territory ceases to be God’s territory and Satan attacks it: their followers, who are called Sunnis, abduct, kill, lie, commit robbery, act dishonestly, kill one another in broad daylight; the courts fill with lies, and the ulema sleep soundly. Why does no doomsday come over that? Bribery flourishes – no doomsday over that. People begin to violate one another’s rights – no doomsday. This means that in reality the leaders of the various fragments of the Ummah regard them as their territory, and that is what is called politics. As long as something remains within the territory and does not leave it, no doomsday comes; when territorial loss begins, then doomsday comes in politics. This state of politics exists everywhere in the world. If another nation tries to take even an inch of the English people’s land, there will be a reaction – there was a reaction even as far as the Falkland Islands. But when the internal conditions deteriorate, nothing happens to politics: values are abandoned, oppression begins. When religion takes exactly this form, how can it be called religion? It has become politics. If there were love for God, then when God’s servants are leaving God and becoming servants of Satan, a turmoil should break out in the hearts of the ulema: this loss is happening before our eyes!

In the time of the Holy Prophet (saw), importance was given when someone committed an act of irreligiousness. But there were apostates; every day people came and went, and there was no commotion about it. The Holy Qur’an is full of these testimonies. It says that people come daily, in the morning they say ‘we believe’ and in the evening they say ‘we are returning to our former religion’. Despite this testimony in the Holy Qur’an, there is not a single testimony that such people were ordered to be massacred. But where lies were told, where vice and immorality prevailed, there the court of the Holy Prophet Muhammad (saw) was convened and measures were taken for their reform. This is Taqwa and religion. What you see today is not Taqwa and religion; it is only politics.

(Questioner:) So that means there is no chance?

(Hudur:) There is one chance, which the Messenger of Allah (saw) has described. Now transport yourself into the past, to that era of Judaism when the Messiah had not yet come; at that time your fatwa would have been the same that you are giving today. But the era of the Holy Prophet (saw) has not ended; his era lasts until the Day of Judgement. Therefore God the Exalted granted him important tidings up to the Day of Judgement. Among these tidings was the news of a corruption, which I described, and among these tidings was also a way for its reform. Study all such Ahadith: nowhere will you find even by implication that when this state of division arises, the ulema will gather, put their heads together and devise some plan, or that the common people will think up some scheme, or that the Muslims will be given oil wealth and through that wealth carry out reform measures. Not even by implication is this mentioned anywhere. Whenever he spoke of the cure, he spoke of the Mahdi and spoke of the Messiah. Without listening to the One who is the Master of the Ummah, you may devise a thousand proposals of your own – none can succeed. The only thing to decide is whether that Mahdi who has been claimed has come or not, and that Messiah who was prophesied. These are the two decisive matters. If they have not come, then nothing can be done.

(Questioner:) My concern is not whether the Messiah has come or not.

(Hudur:) If it is not your concern, then why are you asking the question?

(Questioner:) My aim is not that connection; I don’t want to get into that debate. My only aim is that we are all Muslims, all the people sitting here.

(Hudur:) How do you know that?

(Questioner:) Because they say about Ahmadiyyat that they are not Muslims; I have come to this gathering and I consider myself a Muslim.

(Hudur:) No, that is not the point; listen to me. What is the definition of Islam? ‘Innamal mu’minuna ikhwa’ – this is one definition stated in the Holy Qur’an. If you try to resolve this dispute over matters of the heart and matters of belief, it is a dispute you can never settle. But the clear signs that the Holy Qur’an has given can be recognised by everyone without education. Among them is this: ‘Innamal mu’minuna ikhwa’ – believers are brothers. And how did the Messenger of Allah (saw) define brotherhood? He said they are brothers like one body; if even the tip of a toe suffers some pain, the whole body becomes restless. This is the spirit of Islam. Does it exist today?

(Questioner:) That is exactly what I am asking too.

(Hudur:) No, you are not; you are saying ‘Muslims’. I say that judged by the spirit of the Holy Qur’an they do not remain Muslims. That is the dispute. Islam cannot survive without Taqwa.

(Questioner:) All right, fine.

(Hudur:) No, it is not a matter of ‘all right’. The fact is that Islam without Taqwa is like moulding a figure of clay and saying it has become a man. In form and appearance it may be a man. You can say that at present we appear Muslim in form and appearance and in terms of beliefs. But the definition of these people which the Holy Qur’an gave and which the Messenger of Allah (saw) explained appears to be missing from the Muslim world. Is this right or wrong?

(Questioner:) Perhaps it is right.

(Hudur:) No, no, you too should exercise Taqwa. Why do you abandon the very Taqwa that is being discussed? Is my statement right or wrong that that definition ‘al-mu’minuna ikhwa’, and the definition that believers are brothers like one body, and if one finger suffers pain the whole body trembles – does it apply today or not?

(Questioner:) I think we Muslims do not care about one another at all; we Muslims are not brothers at all.

(Hudur:) Exactly, that is what I am saying now. That is precisely the problem, the very problem I am explaining.

(Questioner:) I understand the same problem too, but then its basis is wrong, isn’t it? Those who have done wrong … no effort is made in this …

10 of 10 left today