3. (Khalil Sahib from Mirpur, Azad Kashmir, residing in Birmingham:) Hudur, the question is: we have never heard of any government declaring a religious sect a minority or non-Muslim. I think that in Pakistan Ahmadi Muslims were declared non-Muslim because Ahmadi Muslims are educated and, through service to humanity, can prove beneficial to the Pakistani people. Therefore domestic and foreign governments do not want Ahmadi Muslims to be able to do this work. Is my view correct, or is there some other reason?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 20 May 1995
AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense
Question: (Khalil Sahib from Mirpur, Azad Kashmir, residing in Birmingham:) Hudur, the question is: we have never heard of any government declaring a religious sect a minority or non-Muslim. I think that in Pakistan Ahmadi Muslims were declared non-Muslim because Ahmadi Muslims are educated and, through service to humanity, can prove beneficial to the Pakistani people. Therefore domestic and foreign governments do not want Ahmadi Muslims to be able to do this work. Is my view correct, or is there some other reason?
It is a hundred percent correct. The real thing is jealousy. Look, study the history of that movement of the ulema among the Muslims which from the beginning has been devoted purely to opposing Ahmadiyyat: after every attempt, after feeling their failure, they understood that the weapons they used to stop Ahmadiyyat were ineffective; Ahmadiyyat came out of them, and their attitude became stiffer and ever stiffer, until they thought: if the law, the law of the land, declares them non-Muslim, such a great wall will be raised around them that no Muslim can even think of leaping over that wall and entering Ahmadiyyat. This is a very correct analysis you have given. Their aim is not that service to humanity should not happen; their aim is that there is a community in which such character has developed that it attracts by its character, and they have no means of stopping its growth. So they kept erecting walls, first small, then bigger; then they built the wall of declaring them non-Muslim. That too was decided.
When the decision to declare them non-Muslim was made, it was in the era of Bhutto Sahib, in 1974. In the ten years that followed 1974, they saw the pace of Ahmadiyyat becoming ever faster. So much so that in 1974, when the decision was being made by the government, i.e. the proceedings were being completed, I was in Islamabad in the last days of April. I had got wind that something was about to happen, so I had gone there to find out at close range what was actually being cooked up. At that time the problem for the government was that trucks and buses filled with people were coming even from Peshawar to my question-and-answer gathering, and people from a hundred or two hundred miles around Islamabad, having learnt that the Imam of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat had arrived there and that in his gathering everyone is permitted to ask questions openly. Ulema were coming and others too. Now it is on record that the government imposed Section 144 and blocked these people’s routes and said they were not permitted to come here. If we were in the wrong, they should have sent ulema in, who by asking open questions in that gathering, where I was bound to answer everyone, would have proved us false. This is on record. No one can change the government’s records now; they have become history. At the post at Attock, at the bridge, three buses of Pathans were turned back who were coming from the tribal areas or other places to join that gathering. But the weakness was such that the mosque still filled up and people overflowed outside.
The situation reached the point – I have a recording of it, very interesting – that I said: with regard to the military, through whom Ahmadiyyat has in fact been declared non-Muslim, declared outside Islam, a gathering should be held there. So in the military area, on one side of Rawalpindi – what is the area called around the Peshawar Road? Yes, the Cantonment area – a gathering was held there. Their generals came, their brigadiers came, officers of every rank came. It was recorded, and that video is preserved with us. Those officers who at the start eagerly asked questions and tried to prove that the measures taken by the government were right – at the end of my answer you will see some of them weeping, and at the end there was not a single head shaking like this; all were nodding in agreement. This is what created panic, and the decisions that might have come with some delay were then made in haste.
So the real thing is that the opposition from the ulema against divine communities is in reality based more on jealousy than on differences of belief. And this very reason for opposition existed in the time of Hadhrat Messiah (as). Otherwise, what belief had he presented over which doomsday should have broken out? Only this, wasn’t it, that if someone slaps you on one cheek, turn the other. What is dangerous about that? But the scholars of that time knew that this was a revolutionary thing; conditions had ripened so that now this very belief would flourish, and the creed of oppression could no longer prevail. Ahmadiyyat presented the same situation in practice within the domain of Islam, and alarmed by this the ulema made one attempt after another. Then Zia Sahib came, and it happened that they are not permitted to call themselves Muslim, not permitted to recite the Kalima, not permitted to conduct themselves like Muslims, not permitted to call a mosque a mosque, not permitted to call the Adhan. They did all this, didn’t they? What did they achieve in practice? In practice they proved a hundred percent that if anyone bears resemblance to Muhammad (saw), the Messenger of Allah, and his Companions, it is only the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. They could achieve nothing besides, because as a result many people then became Ahmadis: now we have understood who the seventy-two sects were and who the seventy-third is.
If you understand its logic you will be amazed; it is a very deep matter. The Holy Prophet (saw) said that like the Jews my Ummah will be split into seventy-two sects. Fine. There will be a seventy-third community, just as the Messiah created a seventy-third community; that seventy-third community is the right one. When the identifying mark was asked – how will it be known which in this bag of seventy-three is the seventy-third and which are the seventy-two – it was a very difficult question. Because, as Mirza Sahib asked just before you: they are all called eggs, Muslims; all eggs look alike, how do we know which egg is rotten and which is good? So this question was put to the Messenger of Allah (saw), and in this his dignity of messengership and his insight are seen. The question appeared so difficult that it seemed it could have no answer: O Messenger of Allah, how will that seventy-third community be identified? All will be sects of Muslims. Listen to the answer. He said: ‘Ma ana ‘alaihi wa ashabi’ – no difficult sign: the condition in which you see me and my Companions – of these seventy-three not every one will have that condition, only one will; the condition of all the rest will be different from it.
Now what was the condition of the Holy Prophet (saw) and his Companions? The first condition was that they were not allowed to recite the Kalima, and the streets of Mecca, with the blood shed upon them, bear witness that the Companions were given very painful punishments for the crime of saying ‘La ilaha illallah’: the Kalima must not be recited. Second, they were not permitted to call themselves Muslims. When Hadhrat Umar (ra) and some other elders announced near the Ka‘bah ‘we are Muslims’, they were not beaten because ‘you have changed your religion’, but because ‘why do you call yourselves Muslims? We call you Sabi’’ – like ‘Mirzai, Qadiani’; the same kind of idiom was in use there too: call yourselves Sabi’, it does not bother us, but we will not let you call yourselves Muslims. And so a quarrel began. When the Holy Prophet (saw) offered prayer he was stopped from praying, and they said: we cannot tolerate this prayer. The Holy Qur’an says: ‘Ara’aital-ladhi yanha ‘abdan idha salla’ – have you not seen the state of that wretch who, when a servant of God stands up to worship Him, prevents him? What right has anyone to stop him from worship? This was the condition of the Messenger of Allah (saw) and his Companions. A mosque was built in the courtyard of Hadhrat Abu Bakr (ra), and the enemies broke down the wall and demolished that mosque: you have no right to build a mosque. Hajj was part of his beliefs; the Messenger of Allah (saw) was to fulfil the purpose of Hajj, but what happened on the field of Hudaibiyah? He was stopped from Hajj. These are the signs, aren’t they?
Now look at the history of Islam: from the time of the Holy Prophet (saw) till today there is not a single Islamic sect that was forcibly stopped from reciting the Kalima; not a single Islamic sect that was stopped from praying. There have been riots over differences in the manner of prayer, but no one was ever stopped from praying. No one was stopped from Hajj, from building mosques and calling them mosques, from calling the Adhan. Even in the Shia Adhan there are words such as ‘‘Aliyyun wasiyyullah’ and the like, yet the Muslims tolerated it and did not stop the Adhan. All these things were imposed in full as punishment upon the Ahmadis in 1984: desist from reciting the Kalima or you will be beaten; if you recite the Kalima, the punishment is death. We consider it to that extent of the Messenger of Allah (saw) that an Ahmadi should say ‘Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah’. Did all these things come together in favour of Ahmadiyyat or not? If they did, then the last nail in the coffin – they call the casket a ‘coffin’ – was hammered in by Zia Sahib with his own hand. What was inside it? The seventy-two sects all agreed: Ahmadis are separate, we are separate; however much we may differ among ourselves, do not call us non-Muslim, do not stop our prayers, do not stop our Kalima, do not object to our manner of worship; we have all now become one; there was only one trouble which we have thrown out. That was the decision, wasn’t it? And what was the decision of the Messenger of Allah (saw)? When there are seventy-two and one, who will be true? Of the seventy-two and the one – the one. And what is their decision? The seventy-two. So that decision is the first organised rebellion of the Muslim world in the name of Islam, in the name of the Messenger of Allah (saw), against the Messenger of Allah (saw). Never before had the Muslim world been involved in rebellion against any decision of the Holy Prophet Muhammad (saw). Some beliefs of a sect were regarded as rebellious, but agreement, consensus (Ijma‘) – here you see that consensus for which there is no counter and no solution: all sects decided that the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat is outside the fold of Islam, and only it is outside the fold of Islam; all the remaining sects may hold whatever beliefs they like, they are inside the bag of the seventy-two of Islam. That was exactly the debate – who will be outside and who inside. Fine. But about jealousy you are, by the way, right.