8. Assalamu alaikum. Respected Sir, on what grounds have the followers of this community of Ahmadiyyat been declared disbelievers in Pakistan? This is today’s situation and known to all. Before that, it has been narrated to me that around the time of my birth or shortly before, your emissaries went to Afghanistan and the government of Afghanistan already issued this fatwa, declared them disbelievers and had them executed – you must know this. In this light: why did Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Sahib not content himself with calling himself a Mujaddid, Muhaddith or Imam of the age, as other revered Imams have been and still are – the example of Imam Khomeini is before you – and why did he claim to be the Promised Messiah or the Mahdi? In the Hadith there are countless narrations that the Promised Messiah will come, will be lowered at the minaret of the Kaaba, will kill the Dajjal of that time at a place [Ludd?], will establish his rule for a period and will dispense justice. You and Mirza Sahib have also explained justice, but all these narrations do not agree with the Hadith. Regarding the Mahdi, narrations say he will be from the family of the Messenger, and many Shias call him the hidden Imam who will appear.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 20 May 1995
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Assalamu alaikum. Respected Sir, on what grounds have the followers of this community of Ahmadiyyat been declared disbelievers in Pakistan? This is today’s situation and known to all. Before that, it has been narrated to me that around the time of my birth or shortly before, your emissaries went to Afghanistan and the government of Afghanistan already issued this fatwa, declared them disbelievers and had them executed – you must know this. In this light: why did Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Sahib not content himself with calling himself a Mujaddid, Muhaddith or Imam of the age, as other revered Imams have been and still are – the example of Imam Khomeini is before you – and why did he claim to be the Promised Messiah or the Mahdi? In the Hadith there are countless narrations that the Promised Messiah will come, will be lowered at the minaret of the Kaaba, will kill the Dajjal of that time at a place [Ludd?], will establish his rule for a period and will dispense justice. You and Mirza Sahib have also explained justice, but all these narrations do not agree with the Hadith. Regarding the Mahdi, narrations say he will be from the family of the Messenger, and many Shias call him the hidden Imam who will appear.
Your question, mashallah, has encompassed quite a range of controversial topics. If you permit, I will begin; where I stop and questions remain, you will get another opportunity. One question is why we were declared non-Muslims in Pakistan. I have actually answered this already when I mentioned the hadith of the seventy-two and said that there would be a seventy-third community distinct from them. The conclusive proof that this is that community is that the seventy-two jointly decided that despite their differences they were all Muslims and this sect was outside Islam. Is that correct or not?
[Questioner: That is correct, but the seventy-two sects – actually there are twelve major ones each divided into six, making seventy-two.] That relates to the Jews, not to Islam. [No, it relates to Islam.] Listen: I have studied the history; the mention of seventy-two sects is found in the history of the Bible – twelve tribes divided into six each, twelve times six made seventy-two, though the name used there translates as seventy, not seventy-two. But that is a minor discussion. The Holy Prophet (saw) nowhere said that in my Ummah first twelve will form and then twelve times six will make seventy-two; he only said the Ummah will split into seventy-two sects. We have no right to read into it what he did not say. Listen to me calmly; I will answer all your points.
In Islamic history, from the very start of differences, whenever a new sect arose the other sects issued fatwas against it and it against them; this has always continued. But for the first time in Islamic history it happened that seventy-two sects reached a consensus and jointly decided that despite their differences they were entitled to be called Muslims, and this sect had such differences that it was no longer entitled to be called Muslim. Am I saying this correctly or wrongly?
[Questioner: The narration is that the Holy Prophet (saw) was asked which sect would be on the right path, and he said: one from among the seventy-two.] No, listen patiently. Attributing something to the Holy Prophet (saw) is very strictly forbidden – I do not want to say the words; they would hurt you. I have cited the narration; this accepted narration is in Shia treatises and books, in Sunni books, and the Wahhabis too, whose sect began with Imam Abdul Wahhab, have quoted it. The words are: he said that one – he did not call it a sect (firqa), he called it a Jamaat – its identification is “ma ana alaihi wa ashabi”: it will be found in the state in which I am and in which my servants and companions are; recognise it by that.
[Questioner: In addition, as Imam … (rh) explained in his hadith collection, that community will be in the majority and you should turn to the majority.] That is not correct, because the hadith points to the opposite. An interpretation of the Holy Prophet’s (saw) words that contradicts his own statement is unacceptable, however great the Imam’s name. He said the Ummah will have split into seventy-two sects – the whole Ummah – after which this community will appear. [Questioner: The word “after” is not there.] Read the hadith again: the Ummah will be split into seventy-two sects, then about the community he said it will be the seventy-third – he used the word seventy-three. How does the seventy-third community suddenly become the majority? [Questioner objects.] One moment – you have come to ask questions. You are a professor; you are not used to students speaking to you and rejecting your view with an argument, so you adopt the same attitude with me. You have asked your question; have patience. Just as when a student asks you, you expect him not to interrupt repeatedly and to listen to the answer, listen to my answer; satisfying you is then Allah’s work.
First: the picture the Holy Prophet (saw) drew is of the whole Ummah splitting into seventy-two. The so-called great majority (sawad-e-azam) is the whole Ummah – what else? It will be divided into seventy-two sects; then there will be a seventy-third community, about which he said it will go to paradise. Tell me, how will it suddenly be in the majority? Who will bring this community into being? Look at the other hadith about the seventy-two, which says they will resemble the Jews. Go back to the time of the Messiah: the Mosaic Ummah, divided into seventy-two sects, did not suddenly become a minority. For a long period persecution of the Messiah’s followers continued, and only over three hundred years did the great revolution occur whereby the Messiah’s followers became the majority and his opponents a minority. The same had to happen here if this Messiah is true.
As for your question about the Mahdi, there is a very clear answer. You said the Mahdi is to be from the family of the Messenger (Al-e-Rasul) – correct. But you have probably not kept all the narrations in view. Being of the Messenger’s family or Ahl-e-Bait has two meanings: spiritual and by blood, and both are established from the Holy Qur’an. For example, about Noah’s son, despite being called Noah’s son, Allah says: “He is not of thy family.” So the idiom Ahl-e-Bait applies spiritually as well as physically. The point is whether the Holy Prophet (saw), in calling the coming Imam Ahl-e-Bait, means spiritually or physically. If one wants to solve this with righteousness, conclusive proof exists in the Hadith and the Holy Qur’an. The Holy Qur’an has not named the Imam of the latter days Imam Mahdi; you will find this nowhere. But it has called him the second era of Hazrat Muhammad (saw), the second advent of the Holy Prophet (saw); the Imam Mahdi has been made so subordinate to Muhammad as if it were the second coming of the Holy Prophet (saw) himself; he will bring nothing of his own. This is mentioned in Surah Al-Jumu’ah: “And among others from among them who have not yet joined them; and He is the Mighty, the Wise” – after the advent of the Holy Prophet (saw) He said this Messenger will also be raised among the later ones; they have not yet met, i.e. there is a gap of time. “That is Allah’s grace; He bestows it on whom He pleases” – which showed that Muhammad (saw) would not return himself, but a representative of his would come who, because of his subordination to Muhammad, would be called his coming; but it is Allah’s grace, He gives it to whom He wills. This verse raises questions. The question is whether the Holy Prophet (saw) himself solved these questions or not. If it is conclusively proven that he did, and your Mahdi of the Ahl-e-Bait is also briefly included, the matter becomes clearer. Listen: when this verse was recited, other companions were sitting with the Holy Prophet (saw); one asked who is meant by “others from among them who have not yet joined them” – that the second advent will be among people who have not yet joined the first. The Holy Prophet (saw) answered – it is a hadith of Bukhari, also accepted in Shia hadith, a hadith on which Sunnis and Shias all agree: Salman al-Farsi (ra) was sitting beside him; he placed his hand on his shoulder and said: “Even if faith were at the Pleiades (Thurayya)…” [recording ends]