2. However, some supplementary questions arise. [Huzur: Ask them now, or leave them for later, as you wish.] The question that arises is: slavery is itself such an institution that, if it is given permanence …
Urdu question-and-answer session, 8 July 1995
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: However, some supplementary questions arise. [Huzur: Ask them now, or leave them for later, as you wish.] The question that arises is: slavery is itself such an institution that, if it is given permanence …
Very good that you raised this question. When I began the answer, I had it in mind to finish here, but I had forgotten. Jazakallah. Now the question is what the status of the institution of slavery is. One is the necessity of war, and the other: can any human permanently make someone a slave? As far as permanent enslavement is concerned, no other means of enslavement is mentioned in the Holy Qur’an. Rather, addressing the Holy Prophet (saw), it says that it is not permissible for anyone to enslave another, except that you fight, and such a fight in which blood is shed, i.e. actually a war, not a skirmish. Skirmishes also used to happen: there was an encounter, various bands fought with one another – as a result of these, enslavement is not permissible according to the Holy Qur’an. 'Hattā yuthkhina fil-ard': it is not permissible for a Prophet to take any slave by any means, except 'hattā yuthkhina fil-ard', i.e. until he is engaged in such a battle as a result of which blood is shed, and that is regular warfare. One route to enslavement was kept – defensive war; in our context, in the context of Islam, this war is only defensive, but it is war nonetheless. And besides this, many ways of freeing slaves were opened. It is like water entering a vessel by one way, and holes being made on all sides so that the water flows out of it. Thus the teaching found in the Holy Qur’an for the freedom of slaves, partly obligatory, partly voluntary, has no parallel in any religion in the whole world. It is astonishing. When you read that slaves will only be made in this way and will become free in this way and that way, one is reminded of that cartoon in which a fight between a cat and a mouse was shown, in which the mouse, Western-style, pulls out a pistol and starts firing at the cat, and she is filled with holes; when, alarmed, she drinks water, it spurts out from every side like a fountain. That is exactly the picture of Islam’s teaching on slavery: the ways of enslaving restricted, and the ways of freedom opened. And provision was made not only for the freedom of slaves who came into Muslim hands through war, but in the whole of society for the slaves who were made in various countries too. Thus it was said: buy them and set them free. So on one occasion a Companion who, by God’s grace, was very wealthy bought sixty thousand slaves and freed them, because he understood from the teaching in the Holy Qur’an that this is a very good means of earning reward. And when minor wrongs, such as are commonly done to servants, were done to slaves, the Holy Prophet (saw) took notice of it so strictly that it is narrated about Ibn Mas‘ud that once he was beating a slave when the Holy Prophet (saw) arrived. There was such anger on his face, and he said repeatedly: Ibn Mas‘ud, Ibn Mas‘ud, what are you doing? He thought that if I do not take some action at once, perhaps I will go to Hell, and said: O Messenger of Allah, I free this slave. He said: then you did right; had you not, you would have come under God’s punishment. So the ways to freedom were opened so widely and their rights were cared for so much that, despite actually being called slaves, they began to consider themselves better than the free. Thus it is mentioned about Hazrat Ali (ra), and about other Caliphs too, that once they went to the market – there is a particular narration about Hazrat Ali – and instead of one he had two pieces of the same kind of cloth cut. The shopkeeper asked: you are taking cloth of the same colour and the same pattern. He said: I need it for my slave too. He said: other kinds of cloth can be provided for a slave. He said: no, Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), said: what you wear yourselves, clothe the slave with that; what you eat yourselves, feed the slave with that. And this model of treatment of slaves bound slaves to the love of their masters to such an extent that its highest example appeared in the person of the Holy Prophet (saw) himself – in the search for his slave Hazrat Zaid. At that time too it was custom that slaves had been made earlier; Islam does not permit making new slaves, but it permitted buying slaves. That is the difference between the two. Those who have already been enslaved – if you do not buy them, they will go to others and suffer greater harm; among them there is not even a concept of freeing them, whereas here a complete teaching of freeing them exists. So when the parents of Hazrat Zaid, after searching and searching, finally reached Medina, and the Holy Prophet (saw) was informed that they had come and wished to take their son, he said: fine. No condition of paying a price, nothing. He called Zaid: look, these are your parents, from whom for some reason you were separated and enslaved. Now I give you freedom: if you wish, go with your parents, you have my full permission. He said: but O Messenger of Allah, what kind of freedom is this? I do not like this freedom. At no price would I leave you and prefer a life of freedom with my mother and father. And this is that Islamic teaching on slavery which in reality enslaved hearts and ruled over them. And there was also teaching that applied, besides refined natures, to comparatively hard-hearted people. These teachings, for instance, are for those who become very cultured and, benefiting from Islamic teaching, advance to a high human level. Those who are lowly do not want to let go of slaves easily. Even in our own times we have seen that among us there are very refined, service-minded, good-natured people, and some hard-hearted ones too. For them the Holy Qur’an gave this command: that if a slave wishes to be freed and decides to pay his price, he cannot be stopped by law, and immediate payment of the price is not necessary either. This is called mukātaba. And if there is a disagreement, the slave can bring a case in an Islamic court: I want freedom, and I am ready to return the price set for me, which he paid; at present I do not have the means, but I guarantee that as I earn I will pay my price. Then according to Islamic law the Islamic court will necessarily decide that the slave be freed. Now tell me, has any hole been left that could have been made and was not made? [Questioner:] Jazakallah. Until now I had heard apologetics, but the way Huzur has explained it, it seemed as though it was in my own heart too.