5. (The questioner comes from a family whose father had joined the Lahore Ahmadis, and is pledging allegiance today.) Hazrat Maulvi Muhammad Ali Sahib and Hazrat Khwaja Kamal-ud-Din Sahib were among the Companions and rendered great services, but they separated from Khilafat. What were the reasons that deprived them of Khilafat? And can the Lahore Ahmadis (Ahl-e-Paigham) be brought back under the umbrella of Khilafat, and how?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 8 July 1995
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: (The questioner comes from a family whose father had joined the Lahore Ahmadis, and is pledging allegiance today.) Hazrat Maulvi Muhammad Ali Sahib and Hazrat Khwaja Kamal-ud-Din Sahib were among the Companions and rendered great services, but they separated from Khilafat. What were the reasons that deprived them of Khilafat? And can the Lahore Ahmadis (Ahl-e-Paigham) be brought back under the umbrella of Khilafat, and how?
The answer to the first part I have discussed in detail in my book 'Fazl-e-Umar', the biography of Fazl-e-Umar, at the end of its first volume: what the reasons were that compelled them to separate – or one should not say 'compelled', because there was no compulsion to separate – what weaknesses remained within their selves, as a result of which they adopted a rebellious attitude towards Khilafat. All the details are there with specific references. It is true that they rendered many services. But it is also true that Allah informed the Promised Messiah (as), and it is in his Tadhkirah, that about Maulvi Muhammad Ali Sahib, on the Day of Judgement the Promised Messiah (as) will say: you too were righteous and had good intentions, so come and sit with us. So as far as God’s treatment of them with forgiveness is concerned, that is Allah’s business; it may be that in view of their past good deeds and services He forgives them. It is not permissible for any Mubai‘ (one who has pledged allegiance to Khilafat) to say that the matter of forgiveness of the Ghair-Mubai‘in is finished. Allah forgives whomever He wills; He is the Master.
But certain things were clear, as a result of which it appeared that they would separate. It is a very detailed subject; briefly, I will tell you this: the Promised Messiah (as) established an Anjuman in his lifetime, and legal advice was taken as to what the status of this Anjuman should be. The background was that there were many administrative matters in which there was a danger that the law might directly implicate the Promised Messiah (as). Administrative decisions are made daily, there are financial matters; if some worker of the Anjuman, God forbid, became dishonest, or there was some financial irregularity – these were the dangers presented to the Promised Messiah (as). So he approved the proposal to found an Anjuman. This was not a revealed Anjuman; rather, it was formed out of need, as a matter of expediency. Hazrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) was appointed president of this Anjuman, and other members were appointed. The legal wording was drafted by Khwaja Kamal-ud-Din Sahib himself and some other lawyers. From a legal point of view it was necessary to present this Anjuman as autonomous; had it not been presented as autonomous, the very difficulty in view – that no one should directly implicate the Promised Messiah (as) and hold him answerable – would still have remained. So the Anjuman was established. Legally it appeared as though the Anjuman had, as it were, taken over. But it was established in the time of the Promised Messiah (as), not after his demise, and in all matters the Promised Messiah (as) remained the final authority whose instructions were to be obeyed. In his lifetime the Anjuman did not even imagine taking advantage of those legal powers to say: the Promised Messiah (as) now remains in charge of spiritual matters, the administration is ours. Rather, they sat completely silent.
Despite this Anjuman having been established, the Promised Messiah (as) wrote the treatise 'Al-Wasiyyat' when he received news of his demise – he received it from the Almighty. He said: now I am about to leave you; do not be grieved by my separation, for after I go you will see the Second Manifestation (Qudrat-e-Thaniya), which will not appear while I am present. And it is the Second Manifestation which God will keep established until the Day of Judgement, and it will protect you. And this has been decreed from eternity: that when a Prophet closes his eyes, Allah the Almighty sends in his place a second manifestation. In the beginning people rejoice and mock, but when the Second Manifestation establishes its hold, progress then begins more than before. The Anjuman already existed beforehand; it was not the Second Manifestation – a very clear, obvious matter. Therefore the Second Manifestation that appeared after the demise appeared in the form of Khilafat. And on the hand of Hazrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) all the workers of the Anjuman and everyone collectively took the pledge of allegiance, and whatever remained, that matter too was settled. The Anjuman wanted to present itself as legally autonomous, but the fact was that in the lifetime of the Messiah (as) the Anjuman had not taken even an iota of that authority into its hands. And when Hazrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) was elected Khalifa, the whole Anjuman unanimously accepted him as Imam and acknowledged that even if the Anjuman had some separate status, it was entirely handed over to this Khalifa; by pledging allegiance at his hand we enter the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. It was a formal pledge of allegiance.
The real reason that emerged after this was that in Hazrat Khalifatul Masih II (ra), that is, my late father, the son of the Promised Messiah (as), certain qualities began to come clearly to the fore, and his popularity in the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat grew day by day. Hazrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) too gave the greatest importance to his advice in consultations, and he enjoyed his full patronage. At that time these elders became anxious: the allegiance to Khalifatul Masih I has taken place, he was elderly in himself and also president of our Anjuman, so in practice no harm was done – because the Promised Messiah (as) had even said: I am forming an Anjuman, legally let it be whatever it may be, but the single vote of Maulvi Nur-ud-Din will outweigh the whole Anjuman. Understand? In this respect the central position remained with Hazrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) anyway. When they had pledged allegiance, the worry arose lest this one become Khalifa: the Khalifa who has been elected is old, over eighty, and this young man is twenty-four or twenty-five, whatever his age was then. If he is elected Khalifa, then all of us will come under his supervision and will have to pledge allegiance at his hand. This psychological complex was eating at them day by day, since they considered themselves the leading members. Then the clauses of the Anjuman that had been inserted out of legal necessity began to appear to them as the means of their salvation. They even began, in the lifetime of Hazrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra), to claim that the status of Khalifatul Masih I exists merely because the Anjuman made him Khalifa; had the Anjuman not made him, he would not have attained this honour and respect and the station of one who must be obeyed. That was these people’s decision, and they started propaganda for it.
When these things were presented to Hazrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra), he delivered that address which holds extraordinary importance in the history of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. He said: look, this propaganda is going on, I know of it. I tell you that Khilafat is not a soda-water bottle from some shop that you buy and use. God has made me Khalifa, just as He made Khulafa before me; the same God made me who made Abu Bakr, who made Umar. Therefore, the members of the Anjuman who say, we have made him, so obey – if the Anjuman made me, I would not even spit on such a Khilafat; in my sight such a Khilafat is not worth a penny. God has made me, so repent, otherwise you will become like the Kharijites. This was a warning, and all these members were present, and there is not the slightest difference in any narration about this. This sermon, delivered with great majesty, had such an effect that in the mosque there was a wailing as if goats were being slaughtered, an uproar of weeping and lamentation, and these people were foremost in seeking forgiveness. They said: O Hazrat, forgive us whatever has happened from our side, from whomever; pardon us, henceforth we repent. On one side they repented, on the other the same danger was again present, and they turned away from their repentance in such a manner – and there is definitive proof of this on record – that gradually, instead of calling the decisions of Hazrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) the decisions of the Khalifa, they began to say: this is the decision of the president of the Sadr Anjuman Ahmadiyya, therefore we accept it. So the mischief remained.
When Hazrat Khalifatul Masih I (ra) passed away, these people rose up and said there is no need for Khilafat. Those Companions who had understood Khilafat, who knew that the Second Manifestation had appeared in the person of Hazrat Khalifatul Masih I and that the Anjuman had no status in comparison to it, stood up and said: there is no question of that; today itself we will elect a Khalifa and take the pledge of Khilafat. So the overwhelming majority of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat that was present there elected Hazrat Mirza Mahmud Ahmad as Khalifatul Masih II and pledged allegiance. At that time these few elders who were left stood without support; they were compelled to migrate from Qadian, because there the overwhelming majority consisted of those who had entered the allegiance of Khilafat. And this wrong action of theirs, too, happened by Allah’s decree; had they remained in Qadian, it would have been a great mischief. So they left of their own accord. And since the secretary …