6. [The question is not included in this excerpt; this is the continuation of an answer about the split after the election of Hazrat Khalifatul Masih II (ra) and why many followed the Lahoris.]
Urdu question-and-answer session, 8 July 1995
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: [The question is not included in this excerpt; this is the continuation of an answer about the split after the election of Hazrat Khalifatul Masih II (ra) and why many followed the Lahoris.]
… as the Anjuman. The other offices were mostly in their hands too. So they used them and emptied the entire treasury. Of everything there was, only six annas remained in the treasury. Then they went back and boasted in their newspaper which came out later, and the report about this is preserved in print: Now we will see how he runs his Khilafat; only six annas are left in the treasury. Then they claimed that the outside majority of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat was also with them; ignore those present in Qadian. This is the same mischief as that of the Kharijites. It was said back then that the decision on the Khilafat of Hazrat Abu Bakr (ra) or Hazrat Umar (ra) and others was made by the people present in Medina; the Muslim world had not gathered, and there was no need to accept it as the decision of the Muslim world. And this school of thought continues in Islam to this day. The same stance was adopted here, and it was said that this decision was that of the people present, but the entire outside majority was with them. There were also some leading figures who were influenced by the Anjuman and had not had the chance to live in Qadian and receive long training. When they read the legal wording, they got the impression that Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as) had, as it were, made the Anjuman his successor. Therefore a large number were deceived and went along with these people. And they also began to announce that the majority was with them. Hazrat Khalifatul Masih II (ra) said: Look, God is with me. God has caused me to be elected Khalifa. Neither will your treasuries be of any use, nor will your majority remain a majority. You will see what happens next and on whose side the divine numbers are. And today the situation is that only sporadically, in some countries of the world, is any organised presence of the Lahoris visible; in most places it has either been wiped out or become insignificant. And after the decision of 1974, among those living in Pakistan there were many who repented and returned to the great majority (Sawad-e-A’zam); indeed they even handed over their own mosques to those clerics who had started forcibly occupying mosques. That is divine decree on one side. The same decree later brought back many leading figures who had joined them. For example, Ghulam Hasan Khan Sahib, who was the father-in-law of Hazrat Sahibzada Mirza Bashir Ahmad (ra) and a Pathan. Especially in the Frontier, the Lahoris had gained great influence, because most Pathans at the time had become Ahmadis under the influence of Sahibzada Abdul Latif Shaheed (ra) or others, but had not had the opportunity to come to Qadian and be trained. They were very impressed by these people; they were people of status, editors of journals and holding high positions in large Anjumans. So most Pathans of the Frontier joined these people. And the greatest harm to the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat in this came through the personality of the late Ghulam Hasan Khan Sahib, his standing and his piety. His family was very respected and quite influential. Even though he was related by marriage to Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as) – the son of Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as) was his son-in-law; he was the father-in-law of Hazrat Mian Bashir Ahmad (ra) – despite this close relationship, when he did not take the Bai’at, it became a severe stumbling block for many outsiders. They said there must be something in it, and so they stayed with them. In the last part of his life – he was a man who would not yield and argued very hard; he argued with this legal text and said that after it he would not enter into any debate – he came to Qadian in his old age. I saw him myself. He stayed at the house of Hazrat Mian Bashir Ahmad (ra), and one day, when he announced his Bai’at, Hazrat Mian Bashir Ahmad (ra), who respected him greatly, asked him: You spent your whole life debating and listened to no one; what has prompted you now to decide on the Bai’at? He said: Look, that was the reasoning of my mind, and I honestly held to it and kept refusing. But the Bai’at that is now taking place is happening through the might of divine decree. When I saw that God stands with them and not with those others – and religion is for the sake of God – I decided: all my arguments on one side and God’s decision on the other. That is why I have decided on the Bai’at. It is true that minorities are sometimes in the right against the majority. But it never happens that the majority is in the right and the minority devours it. These are two different things. If the minority is true, then whenever it clashes with the majority it grows and spreads. If the majority is true, the minority can do nothing to it. That is the point here. They said: You are in the minority and have no standing. But by the decree of God – if they were true, why did He make that truth a minority? When His decree is: “Kam min fi’atin qalilatin ghalabat fi’atan kathiratan” (How many a small party has overcome a large party). At the beginning there are also small communities, but this law certainly operates that they overcome the large communities. It is never a law that truth is on the side of the majority and is overcome by a minority. So this was the divine decree he was referring to. [Brief exchange about the name:] Muhammad Aslam Khan Sahib … – it was Ghulam … Sahib, wasn’t it? – Ghulam Hasan Sahib, the father-in-law of Hazrat Mian Bashir Ahmad (ra). So this is the position. I hope you understand the reasons why these stumbling blocks occurred. All right?