7. [Question barely audible; in essence: Can the Lahoris/Paighamis be brought back collectively into the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat on the basis of an agreement?]
Urdu question-and-answer session, 8 July 1995
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: [Question barely audible; in essence: Can the Lahoris/Paighamis be brought back collectively into the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat on the basis of an agreement?]
I submit: they cannot be brought back on the basis of a formal agreement. That is against the interests of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat. Let me give you an example. When I went to Fiji, there was at that time Abdul Hafeez Khan Sahib, who was very respected and very influential among the Paighamis there. He invited me to come to his house and have a discussion, because he wanted a decision to be reached. I told him: Let me make one thing clear to you: I am not prepared to accept all the Paighamis into the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat as the result of a collective decision. This is an individual matter. Whoever is satisfied about Khilafat will join; whoever is not – why should we do it for the sake of political decisions? So that is my condition; I will not come under this misconception. He said: Fine, come; give us a chance for questions and answers. But the condition is that no other Ahmadi comes with you. He thought that others would prompt me, the way people sit beside the Imam. The local Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat became afraid that these were powerful people and some trouble might arise or some harm be done. They were very worried and said I should not go. I said: I am certainly going, and you are not; the decision will be mine. So no other Ahmadi went with me; I went to his house alone. He was a very wealthy and influential man, owner of a large house, and he had invited Paighamis, old and young, from far and near, and said: Look, I have presented this Khalifa of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat before you; whatever questions you have, ask him; there is no need to ask any Maulvi, and decide for yourselves. So the session there continued until about two or half past two at night – the night was far advanced – and every question anyone asked, old or young, I answered. After that Abdul Hafeez Khan Sahib said right there: For me nothing remains now; the people have to make the decision. Later Abdul Hafeez Khan Sahib wrote me a letter: As far as I personally am concerned, I am fully convinced, but I am not yet finding the ability to take the Bai’at. Because his relations were not only there in the Nadi area; the district was quite large – he said it was the Nadi district, and elsewhere too – his influence was widespread. He wrote to me: I want to take the Bai’at when I have convinced all the others and brought them along. I wrote to him: I already told you, there is no condition; do as you wish. But it is a strange decree of God that he died before he could take the Bai’at. The benefit, however, was that many others then joined. Accepting them collectively is not appropriate in my view. If we take them in through negotiation, what will happen? Some of their conditions will remain. Their lack of training is more dangerous than that of non-Ahmadi Muslims. Despite accepting, they have adopted an independent way of thinking in opposition to Khilafat. And because of this crooked thinking, when they become Ahmadis they create more problems for us than those non-Ahmadi Muslims before whom the veil has been lifted, and who then submit completely and stay with us with full sincerity and loyalty. But with the Paighamis we have seen in most cases – not every one, but mostly – a constant headache: here some remark against the Nizam, there something against the Nizam, not accepting this, not accepting that. These habits that form are very hard to break. May Allah grant – outwardly it appears from you that you do not have such a habit. But if you do, then reform will come through prayer, not through questions.