8. [After introduction: Muhammad Ratish(?) Sahib, not an Ahmadi, attending for the first time.] Your Honour, I watched a video cassette of yours; a friend of mine, who is an Ahmadi, showed it to me. In it you said that the Holy Qur’an states that Hazrat Noah (as) lived nine hundred and fifty years, but human reason does not accept this. [Huzur: Did I say that?] Yes, you said that his natural age was not nine hundred and fifty years, but his Shariah age was nine hundred and fifty years. Do you have any proof for this from the Holy Qur’an? The Holy Qur’an is a complete book; you yourself say we cannot shift even a zer or zabar in it. If we cannot do that, then … You further said: if Hazrat Noah lived nine hundred and fifty years, why did he not meet Hazrat Abraham (as), who came nine hundred years after him? And you said no historian has written that Hazrat Noah and Hazrat Abraham met each other. Is it right that we believe a historian when our Holy Qur’an tells us something?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 8 July 1995

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: [After introduction: Muhammad Ratish(?) Sahib, not an Ahmadi, attending for the first time.] Your Honour, I watched a video cassette of yours; a friend of mine, who is an Ahmadi, showed it to me. In it you said that the Holy Qur’an states that Hazrat Noah (as) lived nine hundred and fifty years, but human reason does not accept this. [Huzur: Did I say that?] Yes, you said that his natural age was not nine hundred and fifty years, but his Shariah age was nine hundred and fifty years. Do you have any proof for this from the Holy Qur’an? The Holy Qur’an is a complete book; you yourself say we cannot shift even a zer or zabar in it. If we cannot do that, then … You further said: if Hazrat Noah lived nine hundred and fifty years, why did he not meet Hazrat Abraham (as), who came nine hundred years after him? And you said no historian has written that Hazrat Noah and Hazrat Abraham met each other. Is it right that we believe a historian when our Holy Qur’an tells us something?

I want to tell you the reference in the Holy Qur’an. The Holy Qur’an has stated two very interesting things. First, that Hazrat Noah’s age was nine hundred and fifty years, which is also mentioned in the Bible. Of all the long life spans of other prophets mentioned in the Bible, God Almighty did not choose a single one or mention it; He mentioned only that of Hazrat Noah. And at the same time He said about Hazrat Abraham that he was among the Shi’a (followers) of Noah, i.e. Abraham (as) was a follower of Hazrat Noah and believed in him. This point is very important, because: does it mean that Noah was alive and Hazrat Abraham (as) took the Bai’at at the hand of Hazrat Noah, or does it mean something else? The Holy Qur’an does not mention this even by implication. It is not a matter of a historian; I did not use the word historian there. I referred to the heavenly scriptures, to the Bible and the Holy Qur’an: neither does the Bible say anything about this, nor does the Holy Qur’an even hint that in the time of Abraham (as) Hazrat Noah or any other earlier prophet was alive. On the one hand the Holy Qur’an says his age was nine hundred and fifty years; on the other it says Abraham (as) was among Hazrat Noah’s followers; and thirdly it does not even hint at his existence. If his age was nine hundred and fifty years, then Hazrat Noah died only when Hazrat Abraham was sixty years old. Do you understand? And in the account of Hazrat Abraham we find that only idolaters remained, nobody else. And regarding Hazrat Noah – are we then also to accept that Hazrat Noah came, after him countless prophets came, and the final result of his reform that he saw with his own eyes was that Abraham alone accepted and all the rest had become idolaters; and that they became such idolaters that Hazrat Noah left them and disappeared and left Abraham to fight alone? These are things that follow conclusively from the account in the Holy Qur’an. And it is against reason that there should be a contradiction in the Holy Qur’an. When I refer to reason, I do so in reference to these verses in the Holy Qur’an. The Holy Qur’an says that among the followers of Noah was Abraham; the Holy Qur’an says Hazrat Noah had no existence in that era. Is there a contradiction between these things, or is there some other solution? In our view there is no contradiction in the Holy Qur’an. Therefore, regarding the age, one must conclusively understand that it is the age of his Shariah, the period during which he remained among those people as a Shariah. And in terms of this age, we believe the era of Hazrat Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), lasts until the Day of Judgement. And Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as) repeatedly called him a living Prophet who lives even now and will live until the Day of Judgement. There, obviously, physical life is not meant, but spiritual life, and the era – how long his age continues. From this angle, as a result of this deduction, I said about Hazrat Noah’s age that it is not his physical age but his spiritual age, the age of his Shariah. Abraham (as) was born under that Shariah and remained under it for a period, then God Himself made him a law-bearing prophet. And when He did, Noah’s age came to an end; thereafter Noah did not remain alive in terms of Shariah; his era ended and Abraham’s era began. This is the deduction. Do you understand? The verse is: “Wa inna min shi’atihi la-Ibrahim” – after the mention of Hazrat Noah, As-Saffat, verse eighty-six/eighty-four. Allah the Exalted says – Noah has been mentioned before –: “Wa inna min shi’atihi la-Ibrahim”, i.e. among his followers was Abraham. The word “Shi’an-e-Ali” – this is the same word used there, meaning followers. Gradually the word Shi’a has become separate in connection with Hazrat Ali (ra), but its beginning was that people said: These are the Shi’a of Ali, the followers of Ali, not of the other Khulafa. So here Allah the Exalted declares Hazrat Abraham a follower of Hazrat Noah, which means that his Shariah was alive until then and the full nine hundred and fifty years had not yet passed. It makes no mention of Hazrat Noah being alive.
[Questioner: Allah and the Holy Qur’an are a matter of certainty; what is written in the Holy Qur’an is complete certainty for us.] Complete certainty. [Questioner: I only meant that we cannot shift it with our reason or interpretation.] We cannot shift it, as you say, but we can deduce; deduction is commanded. Now, it is written in the Holy Qur’an that men are a garment for women and women are a garment for men. If I say that garment means one should cover each other’s faults, cover each other’s body; a garment clings to the body and knows inner secrets, one should not publicise them – and someone says: it says garment, why are you shifting it? – that is not correct. If I say it is written in the Holy Qur’an that women are your tilth, and someone picks up a plough and sets off to run it over women – would that be permissible? Everyone would say: no, that is not right. Why, it is written in the Holy Qur’an, why should I shift the meaning? Trying to understand the meanings of the Holy Qur’an is something the Holy Qur’an itself asks for. And the Holy Qur’an says that this is the Book in which there are some Mutashabihat – verses whose meaning is not fully within everyone’s grasp – and some Muhkamat. Understand the Mutashabihat in the light of the Muhkamat. And this knowledge Allah grants to those whom God has given this ability and whom He guides. So those who receive guidance from God can, by His grace, understand the meanings of the Holy Qur’an; they do this in accordance with a command. This verse about nine hundred and fifty years becomes mutashabih in relation to the other verses; otherwise a contradiction will appear in the Holy Qur’an. That is why it is necessary; otherwise the enemy will say: what a strange book this is; on one side it says Hazrat Noah lived nine hundred and fifty years, on the other, in the account of Abraham, it declares everyone a non-believer. And what was Hazrat Noah doing, had he ceased to be a believer? How did Abraham alone become a believer in the world? This is the problem that shows a contradiction in the Holy Qur’an. Therefore it is the duty of every servant of the Holy Qur’an to remove this contradiction. And trying to remove a contradiction and to bring out the true understanding is not opposition to the meaning in the Holy Qur’an but its confirmation.

10 of 10 left today