5. (The question is not included in this excerpt; from the answer it concerns Hindu idol and deity worship and the claim that idols are merely a means of concentrating on the one God, “Om”.)

Urdu question-and-answer session, 21 October 1995

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: (The question is not included in this excerpt; from the answer it concerns Hindu idol and deity worship and the claim that idols are merely a means of concentrating on the one God, “Om”.)

This is merely a self-deception of the ego. If the questioner looks deep within himself, he will realise that Om exists somewhere up there, but what is asked for is asked of others. If it is wealth, it is asked of the goddess Lakshmi; if sons are wanted, they are asked of another god. For everything gods and goddesses have come into being. When attention is focused on them, two errors arise. First, that goddess too cannot be seen. One sees an idol of her, and the idol is made in such a way that people become so awed by it that the idol itself dominates the mind and psyche. It is revered as though it were God Himself. If it were only for concentration, put a piece of wood or a lump of clay in front of you; the purpose of concentration would be fulfilled. But kick it aside in worship and say it is only clay. When it is said of such an idol, this is not a goddess, it is an idol, bloodshed follows. If such an idol is damaged – one that was of clay, stone, wood or some metal – then people’s bones are broken and their blood is shed, although nothing has happened to God. If God is something else, then in my view this is a pretext of the ego, and if not a pretext, a self-deception. A psychological shadow falls upon the hearts of such people. They say they have made them a means, but the attention… I do not know about every individual, but the general verdict is this. I was born in surroundings where Hindus lived all around me; opposite our house, in our neighbourhood, Hindus lived. When they worshipped the pipal tree, they did not worship God, they worshipped the pipal tree itself. When they placed an idol before them, they gave importance to the idol itself. That is why you will find stories that an idol drank milk, an idol opened its eyes, an idol moved. These tales about idols were fabricated to show that they possess divine attributes in themselves. Therefore this is nothing but shirk (associating partners with God). Such a dispersion of attention is not for fixing attention on God, but for diverting it. Therefore nothing is asked of the ultimate concept of God; it is asked of these false, artificial concepts. The matter is wrong from other aspects too. I said there are two defects in it. First, those whom they call gods and goddesses are described as having existed in themselves alongside God forever. I have studied the Vedas, not completely but to some extent. I am a great admirer of the Bhagavad Gita as a book; it is a magnificent book, and I have studied it too. I tell you, the actual belief is that just as God has always existed, i.e. Om – some also call Him Indra, some call Him Paramatma – alongside Him, for instance also called Brahma, there are others, and all of them have always existed. The great God did not create these gods; rather, these gods have always been His partners in Godhood. Yes, they are specialists: some have control over the air, some over water, some over earth, trees or souls. So when they have always existed, they are partners of God – how are they servants of God? The further defect, because of which we call Hinduism a polytheistic religion – not in order to hurt their beliefs, but having understood their belief, and with reference to their books, we state what is in fact the spirit of Hinduism – is this: God is not even the creator of souls, God is not even the creator of matter. He has no capacity to create anything from the beginning. Yes, He has power to rule over things and the ability to join them together. And the many gods who have existed in themselves alongside Him from eternity, He did not create them either, nor can He join them together. Yes, their avatars come into the world in the sense that at that time they are God incarnate – this is believed. As far as idols are concerned I have already explained. Now I tell you about avatars: these gods I am mentioning – they have very many names – are not said to be avatars of God; that is not correct. Their avatars come: one person becomes the avatar of one, another the avatar of another. And then they fight wars and battles among themselves. If someone is the favourite of one god and fights his opponent, then the avatar of the god who made him his favourite fights those who are avatars of another god, and then there is great tumult. Read the Mahabharata, that tale; all these things are in it. But I want to say, leave aside the Mahabharata – as far as I have spoken with Hindu friends, and I have had conversations with them for a long time, the belief I am describing is everyone’s belief: that no god created any other god. That one God has them all as partners, and they in turn have manifestations. The god of the sun is one of the four fundamental gods; the sun is his manifestation, but that god is not a manifestation of God; he is God in himself. Therefore I urge the questioner most earnestly to study the Hindu scriptures from this perspective, and you will find all my statements true.

10 of 10 left today