7. (Introductory remark on ‘final question’): Shaukat Ahmad Nasir from Newham: My question is: if a person loves his parents very much and becomes an Ahmadi, but his parents, despite being explained to, do not accept Ahmadiyyat, and he fears that because of not accepting the Promised Messiah (as) they will go to hell – what is Huzur’s guidance on this?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 21 October 1995

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: (Introductory remark on ‘final question’): Shaukat Ahmad Nasir from Newham: My question is: if a person loves his parents very much and becomes an Ahmadi, but his parents, despite being explained to, do not accept Ahmadiyyat, and he fears that because of not accepting the Promised Messiah (as) they will go to hell – what is Huzur’s guidance on this?

(Huzur’s preliminary remark: It is said this is the last question, but not ‘Khatam-us-Sawalat’. Let me tell you an incident: when I was a student at the University of London, our Arabic teacher was Mr. Hopkins. He had us translate the sentence: ‘So-and-so was the last caliph of the Banu Umayyah.’ I deliberately translated: ‘Kana khatam-al-khulafa min khulafa Bani Umayyah’ – he was the Khatam of the caliphs of the Banu Umayyah. He marked it in red: wrong. I went to Arab friends, played innocent and said: does this professor not know Arabic? They said: no, he is a top expert. I said: look, I translated that he was Khatam of the caliphs, i.e. the caliph of the Banu Umayyah who was last in time. The Arabs said: he is right, you are wrong, you do not know Arabic. I said: then do you mean God does not know Arabic either? You say that in the Holy Qur’an Allah uses the word Khatam in the sense of ‘last’. When I did it, I was wrong; if I am wrong, then God is wrong too. Then they understood: Khatam is for honour; Khatam does not mean last in time, otherwise it has no meaning at all.) Answer: As far as hell is concerned, we do give the principled ruling that rejecting someone (sent by God) causes God’s displeasure. But no one has the right to give such a ruling about individuals. For the Holy Qur’an even says that those who believed in Muhammad (saw), and besides them those who became Jews, those who became Christians, and those who believe in other scriptures – if they believe in Allah and the Last Day and do good deeds, no fear shall be upon them. This does not mean those who recognise the Holy Prophet (saw) and reject him; they no longer remain people of true deeds. It refers only to the exceptions: there are many millions of people in the world whom the message of the Holy Prophet (saw) has not reached. You cannot call them Muslims, but if they believed in some messenger who came to them, are good people and also believe in the reckoning – this is necessary so that they watch over their conduct and know they are not unbridled – if such people, even though outside the Ummah of Muhammad (saw), have been given this promise, then it is not permissible to declare every person of the Ummah of Muhammad a denizen of hell merely because he did not believe in the Promised Messiah. The decision to declare someone a denizen of hell rests with Allah. Nor can we decide that they in general are destined for paradise, because the Holy Prophet (saw) likened the state of the Ummah at the time of the coming of the Promised Messiah, its seventy-two sects, to the seventy-two sects of the Jews and said: ‘Kulluhum fin-nar’ – all these sects are in the fire. Whichever sect someone belongs to, the sect has been given the title of hell. This by no means implies that every single individual of that sect is in hell. Among its many meanings, one is: ‘Kulluhum fin-nar’ – a fire is burning within them, the fire of discord, restlessness; they are not granted (righteous) action, and their doctrines are so erroneous that they do not have the ways of the people of paradise; there is no unity, no steadfastness on the Oneness of God. All these matters of religious discord give the verdict that they are in hell, or at least are living a kind of hellish life in this world. Nevertheless, it is by no means permissible for any Ahmadi to call or regard every non-Ahmadi Muslim a denizen of hell. It is possible that among Ahmadis there are those who have taken the Bai‘at in name only but whose character is that of the people of hell. That is why the Promised Messiah (as) clearly said: do not consider yourselves safe merely on the basis of Bai‘at; if you perform deeds that please Allah, you will have the glad tidings of paradise, otherwise not. This is a clarification I wanted to make. If someone tries to convince his parents and they do not believe, then he prays to God and submits before Him; he can do nothing more. He cannot save them through his love. But it is also impermissible to call one’s own parents denizens of hell, because these decisions will be made on the Day of Judgement. Every person considers himself good. Therefore, from a global perspective, the Holy Qur’an has given a very lofty teaching: you have no right to make the decisions of the Day of Judgement. You only have the right to say: from what I have seen in this world and what I believe, this appears true to me, and you appear to me to be on the wrong path; I invite you, and if not, then we pray. That is why the prophets kept admonishing their parents who did not accept them during their lifetime and kept praying for them, but after death God did not permit them to pray; now the matter had passed into God’s hands. This is the ruling on the case you have presented.

10 of 10 left today