5. Hudhur, my second (question): I have seen and heard some of your recent Friday sermons. There are one or two points in them on which I would like clarification. (Hudhur: You listen to the sermons? Good, then go ahead. It is a scholarly discussion. There is a possibility that – since this series too is not closed – many points are yet to open up. If you now mention some points for the sake of understanding, everyone will benefit; I will include them in a future sermon.) In one sermon – in fact I think it extended over two – on ‘Nurun ‘ala Nur’ (light upon light), your discussion was very scholarly and to a large extent scientific too. In it you said that light has a hidden form and a manifest form, and the hidden form is sometimes more powerful, and you gave the example of black holes: they are not visible, but if something goes near them, they pull it with tremendous force. My point is that black holes, if one looks at them, are dead stars – a star that has ended its life and died; there is no light in them. – Secondly: on another Friday you said: ‘The heart of the believing servant is the Throne of the Lord (Arsh-e-Maula).’ My submission is: the believing servant is a descendant of Adam – where was the Throne of the Lord before the creation of Adam?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 3 December 1995
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Hudhur, my second (question): I have seen and heard some of your recent Friday sermons. There are one or two points in them on which I would like clarification. (Hudhur: You listen to the sermons? Good, then go ahead. It is a scholarly discussion. There is a possibility that – since this series too is not closed – many points are yet to open up. If you now mention some points for the sake of understanding, everyone will benefit; I will include them in a future sermon.) In one sermon – in fact I think it extended over two – on ‘Nurun ‘ala Nur’ (light upon light), your discussion was very scholarly and to a large extent scientific too. In it you said that light has a hidden form and a manifest form, and the hidden form is sometimes more powerful, and you gave the example of black holes: they are not visible, but if something goes near them, they pull it with tremendous force. My point is that black holes, if one looks at them, are dead stars – a star that has ended its life and died; there is no light in them. – Secondly: on another Friday you said: ‘The heart of the believing servant is the Throne of the Lord (Arsh-e-Maula).’ My submission is: the believing servant is a descendant of Adam – where was the Throne of the Lord before the creation of Adam?
No, your notion is not correct; from the scientific point of view it is the opposite. First understand the word ‘black’: this achkan (my coat) is black not because it is devoid of light, but because it absorbs all the light into itself and lets nothing go back. The black hole is named black hole precisely because scientists say that it absorbs X-rays and ultraviolet and every other kind of ray – every kind of light – with such force that it leaves nothing to go back. (Questioner: Its gravitational pull is very strong.) No, the gravitational pull is not only for matter, for solid things; it is for everything, for light too; it pulls in light, therefore light cannot be seen – none at all there. Understood? No light outward, but it remains present inside it. It is not itself devoid of light; rather it is brightest within itself, but because it does not let the light escape, no one can see it. That is the meaning of black hole. And now you should also understand why Muhammad (saw), who was brighter than all lights, chose black as the colour of the flag of Islam. It was a black flag, which outwardly seems strange: the brightest prophet in the world has come, the greatest giver of light, and he chose black as the colour of the flag. The real reason is that it points to the absorption of light: a Muslim is one who completely absorbs light into himself; then God produces more light from him – that is a separate matter. But you will become true believers only if you cling to the light, digest it within yourselves, and it becomes part of your being. In this way it outwardly appears as a black colour. But there is another fine point in it too: those beings who were the brightest within Islam appeared the blackest to onlookers. This is the second explanation, and in my view it is the foremost, because Abu Jahl also saw this light and Abu Bakr also saw it; to Abu Jahl it appeared black, and to Abu Bakr it appeared the brightest of lights. This means that to see light an eye is needed; the eye that cannot see light sees blackness. Since the Holy Prophet (saw) used these flags in confronting the enemy, for the believers it was a proclamation that this is light incarnate, and for the others it meant: what you see as darkness, now contend with it and see – will what you seemingly consider darkness prevail, or your light which you consider light? These are all points of spiritual taste, but in a discussion of divine insight such points also come up. I return to the actual point I submitted to you. I only wanted to say that those kinds of light which are more powerful are not visible to the naked human eye. X-rays are far more powerful than the spectrum of light our eyes see, but they cannot be seen. And the Holy Prophet (saw) expressed this subject in a very subtle way – why God is not visible: this light called X-rays, if it fell directly into our eyes, would burn them up. And the Messenger of Allah (saw) used exactly these words in a Hadith: God has put on a veil of light; if He removed that veil, everything would be burned to ashes, no seeing eye could remain. So intensity of light also becomes hidden – this is what I wanted to say. As for the Throne of the Lord: I had not presented just one explanation of it, I presented many. The very first explanation was that the Arsh is a station of transcendence that has no connection with matter and creation – uncreated; that divine station in which attributes are manifest that are above creation and beyond its comprehension too; that is named the Arsh of God in the Holy Qur’an. And the second Arsh is the one before creation; there it says: ‘Kana ‘arshuhu ‘ala-l-ma’’ – His Throne was upon the water. Water here by no means signifies material water, but the water is meant about which it says: ‘Wa ja‘alna mina-l-ma’i kulla shai’in hayy’ – We made every living thing from water. So placing the Throne of God upon the water means that God created life because His relationship was to be connected with life and His attributes were to descend upon life. If this meaning is not taken, then the Throne of God on dead things, which cannot understand, has no meaning. That is why animals too understand to a small extent – they do understand, but only somewhat. The one who most understands God's attributes is man, and among men the one who was made the first Adam, i.e. the prophet, and among prophets the one who understands most is Hazrat Muhammad (saw). So the Arsh relates to the comprehension of God's attributes, and their manifestation within oneself is what it is called. That is why God said: My Throne was upon the water. Otherwise God sitting on water seems a strange thing. But the verses of the Holy Qur’an open up one another's meanings, and very vast mystical meanings emerge. So life was necessary for a relationship with God. Had life not come into being, the chain of creation that sprang from God would have remained lifeless, dead, thoughtless, as if it were nothing, and could not have returned to God. Then, when man became conscious, his thoughts ran towards God and his heart cried ‘Labbaik’ in love, the subject of ‘Inna lillahi wa inna ilaihi raji‘un’ is completed – we came from Allah and to Allah we shall return. So Arsh means foundation; that on which something depends is called Arsh. So God's Godhead, for its foundation – so that My relationship with creation may be established – chose water, and through water created life, and through life man came into being and became a bearer of attributes who could establish a relationship with the divine attributes. And the one who bears the highest divine attributes within himself is Hazrat Muhammad, there is no doubt about it. That is why I had also said that the heart of Muhammad Mustafa (saw) is higher than all thrones – not physically, but where God manifests Himself, that is the meaning of height. Usually the scholars show you ‘high’ like this and ‘low’ like this, whereas in relation to the divine attributes nothing is high on this side and nothing low on that side. God is everywhere, and the directions are turning every way. Now if you call this high, the Americans have become low; and if you call them low, nowadays you will yourself get to the place you had declared low. So talk of high and low must be understood in relation to Allah: whatever moves towards the attributes of the Exalted is high. So if there is a Throne of the Lord in the first place – apart from the transcendent Throne, which is first and remains in its place – it is the heart of Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah, because where God manifested Himself most, that was granted the greatest exaltation. So the subject of raf‘ is also resolved with it. Understood?