10. (Inder Singh Uppal MBE) There is a conflict in my mind which I would like you to try to remove. It concerns a personal experience: some years ago I persuaded a local authority that there should be a community centre here where Hindus, Sikhs and Muslims would have facilities for prayer. With great effort the community centre was built. At its inauguration we decided to invite radio and television, and that all three of our religions – Hindu, Muslim, Sikh – should pray there. I invited everyone, including the Ahmadiyya Association. The Hindu festival went well; there were facilities for ablution and for the Hindus their holy night. I asked that the Ahmadi brother also give the Adhan. There were many Muslims, and there was a very strong protest. (Hudhur: Who protested?) The Muslim community, against the Ahmadi giving the Adhan. My situation became very bad. I said: the Ahmadis are Muslims too; let them give the Adhan, and you give it too. Both were recorded; both gave the Adhan. My misfortune was that when the programme came on television, the Adhan given by the Ahmadi [rest unclear], and they have not forgiven me to this day. That was twenty years ago. I have two requests: first, why did they protest so strongly? They are against me to this day, but I respect them. Second, in the twentieth century can there be no resolution to remove the conflict – can't we live like brothers? Third: is there any unanimity between the Hindu and Sikh religions and Islam?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 3 December 1995

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: (Inder Singh Uppal MBE) There is a conflict in my mind which I would like you to try to remove. It concerns a personal experience: some years ago I persuaded a local authority that there should be a community centre here where Hindus, Sikhs and Muslims would have facilities for prayer. With great effort the community centre was built. At its inauguration we decided to invite radio and television, and that all three of our religions – Hindu, Muslim, Sikh – should pray there. I invited everyone, including the Ahmadiyya Association. The Hindu festival went well; there were facilities for ablution and for the Hindus their holy night. I asked that the Ahmadi brother also give the Adhan. There were many Muslims, and there was a very strong protest. (Hudhur: Who protested?) The Muslim community, against the Ahmadi giving the Adhan. My situation became very bad. I said: the Ahmadis are Muslims too; let them give the Adhan, and you give it too. Both were recorded; both gave the Adhan. My misfortune was that when the programme came on television, the Adhan given by the Ahmadi [rest unclear], and they have not forgiven me to this day. That was twenty years ago. I have two requests: first, why did they protest so strongly? They are against me to this day, but I respect them. Second, in the twentieth century can there be no resolution to remove the conflict – can't we live like brothers? Third: is there any unanimity between the Hindu and Sikh religions and Islam?

Sit on the chair or remain standing, as you prefer. First: you have asked the question of those who did not protest; you should ask those who did. (Questioner: They don't let me speak.) At most they can tell you: we do not regard them as Muslims, so their representing Islam was painful for us; why did you do it? You could have replied: I regard them as Muslims, so I acted according to my understanding, not yours. If you have the right to act according to your understanding, how can you take away my right to act according to mine? Build your own community centre and do not invite them there; in the one I build I will act according to my understanding. Understood? The second matter is unity. (Questioner: Very important.) In the concept of unity there is a misunderstanding that must be removed. Religious beliefs are not changed for the sake of unity. Unity means: while maintaining religious beliefs, treat one another with the finest kindness and do not differ on the human values that are shared. The Holy Qur’an presented this principle very beautifully fourteen hundred years ago: 'Say, O People of the Book, come to a word equal between us and you.' The sense is: you talk a great deal about differences; come together on the word that is common between us. This principle is a golden principle. It does not say, give up your beliefs for the sake of cooperation; it says, cooperate where you agree. In this respect agreement of all the world's religions is possible, because the differences lie only in beliefs, and belief has no connection with daily life. That is between man and God: what Paradise will be like we will only know after death; why fight over it here? What the nature of God is, what angels are like – hold whatever beliefs you wish, but fighting and killing have no connection with that. So keep these differences by all means; God will decide. But the moral teaching God has given is the same in every religion. Despite minor differences, there is no difference that pricks anyone and causes pain. For example, all have taught truthfulness; all have taught sympathy, mercy and compassion. Every one has said: share the sorrow of the poor and share your happiness. Every one has said: do not usurp anyone's property; do not betray a trust; respect elders; be merciful to the young. Is this the teaching of all religions or not? If so, the Holy Qur’an calls thus: 'Come to a word equal between us and you.' Why do you not unite on the things that are common among us? I said: even if there are differences in moral teaching, as far as I know they are not hurtful differences. Christianity will say: forgive, do not take revenge; rather if someone slaps you on one cheek, offer the other. What trouble is that to us? If he offers his other cheek too to the oppressor, what objection does anyone have? Therefore moral teaching, for making the world one community – as far as human interaction and humanity are concerned – is shared, and emphasis should be placed on it. The last question: are there common grounds between the Sikh religion and Islam? Yes, common grounds – the greatest common ground is Hazrat Guru Baba Nanak, whom we regard as our own and you pull to your side. We say he is our Guru; you say no, he has nothing to do with you, and even become angry: why do you call our Guru your own? Not you, but people outside, in Punjab, threaten movements. We tell them: someone making your Guru his own is an honour. If someone pushes you away, then one gets angry; there is no harm in being made one's own. I said: at least do not follow the Muslims of Pakistan, for God's sake; stay firm on your own religion. They are angry with us because we call Muhammad (saw) our own. They say: cut off the relationship, call him – God forbid – a liar, stop proclaiming the Unity of God, then we will embrace you; as long as you call him yours and send blessings upon Muhammad (saw), your punishment is death. I said, do not say such things. This is exactly what I told them when I went to Qadian: fear God. We regard Hazrat Guru Baba Nanak as good, so we embrace him. So he is the common ground. And it is a historical fact that on the cloak (chola) of Hazrat Guru Baba Nanak, which is preserved to this day in Dera Baba Nanak, verses of the Holy Qur’an are written, Surah Al-Fatiha. We have published its photographs, and to this day no Sikh has denied it. That is their decency; I acknowledge it. They could deny it and remain silent, but they do not deny it. Excuses are, however, offered: that a pious Muslim lady wove it and gave it to Baba Ji with this written on it, and since Baba Ji was soft-hearted he kept wearing it out of courtesy. But no truthful person does something against his belief out of courtesy; that is called compromising hypocrisy (mudahanat). Had his belief not supported it, it would have been impossible for Hazrat Baba Ji to wear this cloak to please someone while things contrary to his belief were written on it. Therefore I regard Hazrat Guru Baba Nanak as a Muslim Sufi saint, who performed worship, performed Hajj, and waged a jihad among the Hindus against idolatry. Many Sufi-minded Muslims joined him in large numbers; their joining proves they considered him a Muslim. The remarkable thing is that not a single one of them had a fatwa of apostasy issued against him, and no movement arose in Punjab against them – although Muslims in those days were very strict and the Mullah very bigoted. No one said: look, these have left their religion and gone over to the religion of Baba Nanak, beat them, kill them. They were considered equal among all. This personality is what joins us. (Questioner: I raised the question because in August this year I went to India; there is a town, Faridkot, and in one building there is a picture of Baba Farid, a mosque, and elsewhere a gurdwara.) Yes, that is quite right. (Another attendee:) There is further historical evidence: in Hyderabad, Sindh, on the river bank between two rivers, there is a place where the Hindu sect that regards Hazrat Guru Baba Nanak as true has its site; their old relics and pictures are there, and abundant evidence is found there of what you are describing. Thank you very much.

10 of 10 left today