12. (Syed Nisar Ali Rizvi, Chawinda) First of all I give thanks for the honour of seeing you for the first time. I am visiting here and came through Dr. Zafar Sahib, who said that I would be very impressed by this purposeful gathering. In Pakistan Chawinda is called 'Rabwah number two'; there are many Ahmadis there. My first question was: what is your difference from other schools of thought on the issue of Khatm-e-Nubuwwat (finality of prophethood)? Your Imam has explained something about this, and you too have said something, so I will not stress it much. My second question: Muslims, whether living in Islamic countries or non-Islamic countries, in Europe or elsewhere, in my observation are in their majority – not all – victims of hypocrisy, and often Muslims are called terrorists and fundamentalists. Have you or your Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat made any plan for this problem, what is being done?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 3 December 1995
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: (Syed Nisar Ali Rizvi, Chawinda) First of all I give thanks for the honour of seeing you for the first time. I am visiting here and came through Dr. Zafar Sahib, who said that I would be very impressed by this purposeful gathering. In Pakistan Chawinda is called 'Rabwah number two'; there are many Ahmadis there. My first question was: what is your difference from other schools of thought on the issue of Khatm-e-Nubuwwat (finality of prophethood)? Your Imam has explained something about this, and you too have said something, so I will not stress it much. My second question: Muslims, whether living in Islamic countries or non-Islamic countries, in Europe or elsewhere, in my observation are in their majority – not all – victims of hypocrisy, and often Muslims are called terrorists and fundamentalists. Have you or your Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat made any plan for this problem, what is being done?
(On the place:) The Promised Messiah (as) called Sialkot 'Qadian number two', that after Qadian, Sialkot is second; for me, then, Chawinda has become number two after Rabwah. Both questions are very good. Sit down or remain standing, as you like. In answer to the first question: there is a point I try to explain these days, and many Muslims who do not have much knowledge of the Holy Qur’an and Hadith accept this answer relatively quickly; I will put it before you too. Someone raised earlier that we do not know much; I said that is precisely our difficulty. Explaining to a person who has no detailed knowledge of his own religion and takes hearsay to be religion is very hard, because first he will not even accept that the translation is correct. That is why I have tried to adopt a method in which the debate about translations is removed and it is a plain, clear-cut matter. My position is: if you look honestly, there is in principle no difference whatsoever between our position on Khatam-un-Nabiyyin and that of the non-Ahmadi scholars; it is one hundred percent the same position. The difference is only in identification: whether this is the Imam who was to come. That alone is the difference; in reality there is none. The reason is that all the scholars who say of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat that, with the concept of the coming of a new prophet after Muhammad (saw), it has brought danger into the Ummah, snatched the crown of Muhammad Mustafa (saw) and placed it on the head of a liar and fabricator – and we will not tolerate this shamelessness, the Ummah of Muhammad will not accept it at any price – this is the declaration of the Mullahs. And what you said, that the majority has become hypocritical, applies to them as well, because I will now prove that they themselves believe that, despite the Holy Prophet (saw) being Khatam-un-Nabiyyin, a coming Messiah will appear who will be a Prophet of Allah, and whoever denies his prophethood will be excluded from Islam, and his name is the Messiah, son of Mary. Is this right or wrong? (Questioner: One hundred percent right.) All these scholars who give this interpretation of Khatam-un-Nabiyyin and accuse us agree that despite Khatam-un-Nabiyyin – in the sense that no prophet will ever come now – Jesus (as) is an exception: he will certainly come again and place the crown of Muhammad Mustafa (saw) on his head. This too they believe. The reason is that if the old Jesus comes again, the Holy Qur’an says 'a Messenger to the Children of Israel' – he is the Messenger of Israel; how will he rule over the Ummah of Muhammad? Unless he places the crown of Muhammad (saw) on his head, he has no authority at all to become the leader of the Ummah of Muhammad. So they have accepted two things: that prophethood is not closed in the sense in which… Our statement is different, our belief is different. Our belief is that prophethood continues in the sense that the need for prophethood will certainly arise even after the demise of the Holy Prophet (saw)… [transcript ends]