13. (The question is not contained in the excerpt; from the answer it is evident that it concerned the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat’s understanding of Khatm-e-Nubuwwat (the Seal of Prophethood).)
Urdu question-and-answer session, 3 December 1995
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: (The question is not contained in the excerpt; from the answer it is evident that it concerned the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat’s understanding of Khatm-e-Nubuwwat (the Seal of Prophethood).)
… if there is no need for prophethood, why will the Messiah come, and why will he come as a prophet? If a person does something needless, you call him foolish and stupid. Can you attribute to God that He does something needless? On the one hand He ended the need for prophethood, and on the other He called a prophet – an old one at that, kept somewhere for two thousand years. Why was he kept if there was no need? So they accepted the need, and they also accepted the coming of a prophet. They put forward only one objection, and the point of disagreement is only this: whether an old one will come or a new one. He will certainly come. They say a new one cannot come, as that would break the Seal of Prophethood. And this problem, (in their view,) Allah solved thus: having closed the coming of a new one, Allah remembered that there would be a need and He had closed it – what to do? Allah had already planned: I will keep the old Messiah alive; when the need arises I will bring him and say, look, the Seal of Prophethood is not broken, he has come from the other side; I have called back the earlier one. That is the belief. That is exactly the belief they present on your behalf, on behalf of you innocent people who do not even know what is going on. The maulvis say this is the correct Islamic belief. We say it is wrong. The real point is: the Seal of Prophethood in the sense you hold can only be proven if the need for prophethood comes to an end. If the need for prophethood ends, then there is need neither for an old prophet nor for any prophet. If it has not ended, the need has not ended, then the one who closed it becomes unjust. The world is in need, and someone has closed it. Cutting off water from the thirsty is a great injustice. Yes, if it is said that thirst has vanished from the world, then it is justified for the water to be cut off. But both equally believe in the coming of a prophet; there is no difference. The difference is only: what kind of prophet will come? That alone is the debate. They say that no one from the Ummah of Muhammad will be granted prophethood as a follower (Ummati prophethood) of Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), because the granting of prophethood has ended; the coming of a prophet has not ended. If the coming too had ended, the Messiah could not come either. This has now become completely clear: if the coming of a prophet had ended, where would the Messiah come from? They say the granting of prophethood has ended; no one will be made a prophet. The reuse of an old prophet – like the new use of old clothes after mending – that is permissible, there is no harm in it. That alone is the difference. Our belief is that what you hold is an insult to Islam, a disrespect to Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw). The reason: it is also an insult to the Holy Qur’an. The Holy Qur’an wrote: ‘a Messenger to the Children of Israel’, and thereby bound this messenger to Israel forever. If he comes and claims, ‘O Ummah of Muhammad, I have come to you as your prophet’, then one would have to deem the Holy Qur’an false in order to deem him true. How can both be deemed true at the same time? Where he is deemed true, the Holy Qur’an becomes false; where the Holy Qur’an is deemed true, the one saying this becomes false. Therefore there is no argument in his favour that he has the right to become the prophet of the Ummah of Muhammad. The second and most important point is: who was the first universal prophet? The holy Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw). Whose teaching was universal? His, to whom God said: ‘Say: O mankind, I am the Messenger of Allah to you all.’ Say, proclaim: O all mankind, I have been sent as a messenger to all of you together. Did Moses (as) ever proclaim this? Did any other prophet proclaim it? No. So according to them God is choosing the prophet whom He called a prophet of the Children of Israel and limited there. Now when he comes again, God will necessarily have to give him another kind of prophethood, a universal prophethood, and that will break the Seal of Prophethood as they understand it. If God does not send him as a universal prophet, he has no right at all to interfere in the affairs of the Muslim Ummah. If He makes him universal, it follows that the prophethood he had received was not sufficient; in addition, his prophethood was granted expansion, his rank was raised. What else is making (someone) a prophet? The difference is: we say that the reform God intended, or intends, in the Ummah of Muhammad could be accomplished by the servants of Muhammad, the Chosen One. From among them, God made the one He deemed fit an Ummati prophet. They say: wrong; God will bring the prophet of the Mosaic Ummah from outside to reform you, and in that lies the glory of Muhammad, the Chosen One. What kind of glory is that? A house is raided, the children are weak and cannot defend themselves; the neighbour jumps over and saves them from the robbers – and the children say: we have done you a great favour, you saved us. Is that something reasonable? The rescuer is the benefactor. So they have utterly ruined the theme of the last benefactor as well. The last fountain of grace is Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), and the Holy Qur’an. And it is impossible that any old prophet should come after Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), to dispense grace. And whoever has received grace from his own fountainhead and spreads his light, whether he is a prophet or not, it is the same thing: he is a servant of the king. The maulvis who spread the teaching of the Holy Qur’an do not bring new grace from somewhere else, do they? They take it from the Holy Qur’an. Is there any disrespect in that? What the saints (walis) do is the same work; what the qutbs do is the same work; the truthful ones (siddiqs) also did the same work. So if an Ummati prophet does the same work, how is that disrespect? He has not snatched the crown. If (the old) Messiah comes, he will snatch the crown. Secondly, I submit: about the Mahdi they say, the Mahdi we can accept. They say, up to the Mahdi it was fine, though even that is in doubt, but how did he become a prophet of Allah? Thus there is a group from among ourselves, a group of Ahmadiyyat, which continues to this day under the name of the Lahori group, which says: we will go as far as the Imam Mahdi, no further; we will accept the Messiah without prophet, the Imam Mahdi without prophet. Firstly, when one accepts the Messiah but not as a prophet, one steps outside the statement of the Messenger of Allah (saw) that the coming Messiah will be a prophet of Allah; the Messenger of Allah (saw) was also denied. Secondly, a Mahdi cannot exist without prophethood at all; it is against reason. Put this question to these very scholars yourselves; they will give you the same answer that I now give you on their behalf. Ask them: Sir, Mirza Sahib turned out false; will some Imam Mahdi come or not? Lives have passed in waiting, generations ruined; will he come or not? Will they answer: he will not come? [Questioner:] I too believe in the Awaited One (Muntazar). [Hazrat (rh):] Fine, (let) someone else speak … [Questioner, barely intelligible, roughly about belonging to the Ja‘fari school.] [Hazrat (rh):] Not I – I understand, whichever school you belong to, there is agreement on this: the Imam Mahdi will certainly come. Correct? [Questioner:] But what you related from the Holy Prophet (saw) is the belief of the Sunnis; that is not our belief. [Hazrat (rh):] No, I will show you it is yours as well. I will prove it right now. [Questioner:] Not mine personally. [Hazrat (rh):] Not personally – whether it is yours or not, it is the belief of the Shias. Because they believe that first the Imam Mahdi will appear and then the Messiah will descend from heaven, and the testimony of all the Imams exists for this; there are sayings of the Shia Imams that the Mahdi will descend first and the Messiah afterwards. Do they believe this or not? That is exactly what I was saying. Listen further. Ask them, whether Shia or Sunni maulvis, the answer will be the same: the Imam Mahdi will come. Will you elect him, or will the Iranian government appoint him, or Saudi Arabia? He will surely be from Allah; He who makes Imams will make him. Who will make the Imam? Allah, surely. And Allah will appoint him Imam and then, having made him Imam, give you leave: if you wish, deny him? When Allah makes someone an Imam, will people be permitted to declare him a disbeliever, a denizen of hell, whatever they like – you are free? Can this be? It can never be. Whoever denies the Imam made by God will be cut off from Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw). Is this right or wrong? This is exactly what is called prophethood. Give another definition of prophethood! A prophet is one whom Allah appoints; a prophet is one in whom belief is necessary. ‘He believes in Allah, His angels, His books and His messengers.’ Affirmation of every prophet was made obligatory upon the Ummah of Muhammad; believing in a non-prophet was not made obligatory. Is it obligatory anywhere to believe in such-and-such maulvi or so-and-so? Then why should we believe in the Imam Mahdi? Therefore their state is that they say the thing and also do not say it. As far as the coming of the Imam Mahdi is concerned, they say he will come. As far as his characteristics and attributes are concerned, they say: exactly these. We say: you are describing a prophet; you contradict yourselves. When you have attributed to him the qualities of a prophet, what harm is there in saying it? They say: you say it, we do not. This is exactly what is happening with us. It is like that example – I have related it several times, but it is a very amusing anecdote; those who have heard it enjoy it again on hearing it again, so there is no harm in repeating it. A king had a horse that was very dear to him, and this king was a very powerful and tyrannical king. He learned that his horse had fallen ill and there was no cure. He became very angry and said: my horse, such a magnificent one – who is there to let it die? He said: look, if anyone informs me that my horse has died, I will have him hanged. So beware, it must be cured, and I will not tolerate hearing news of its death. A great commotion arose; the nobles and ministers gathered, the physicians were assembled. They said: there is no cure, we can do nothing; the king has no command over this, over life and death God’s command prevails. (Someone) said: that may be right, but who is going to die (who will tell him)? That is all we care about. They said: a strange difficulty, there is no way out. After consultation it was decided: people keep coming from the villages to the towns; seize the next villager you see coming and tell him: inform the king that the horse has died. This matter had become well known; the one they seized knew it too. He said: you are getting a poor man killed? I have nothing to do with it; it is your responsibility, you go and report it. They said: no, no, it is not like that; we give you only two options: die at the king’s hands or at ours; there is no third option. He said: then, you accursed ones, I would rather die at the king’s hands; why should I die at the hands of base people like you? You seize an innocent man and push him into death. Let me go, I will go and tell him. He was wiser than all of them. He said to the king respectfully: O Your Majesty, congratulations, a hundred congratulations, your horse is perfectly well! The king beamed with joy: good, good, it has recovered? He said: yes, I have seen it myself. (The king:) give me some sign of its recovery. He said: as I was approaching the horse, already from a furlong away the sound of its thrashing could be heard from the ground, and the earth was shaking with it. Now when I reached it, it was lying completely still and motionless; no thrashing. That is how well it has become. The king grew somewhat alarmed and asked: anything else? (He said:) also, when I was approaching, the sound of its breathing was so loud, and when I came close it had stopped completely, no sound at all. And another thing: its heart was beating so hard, as if it were striking not against its chest but against mountains; then I went close, put my ear to it and listened – absolutely, Your Majesty, not a sound; it lies there quietly. At this the king lost his patience; he said: you wretch, why don’t you say it has died? (He replied:) Your Majesty says so, I do not say so. Your Majesty says it; it befits you. The matter was settled. This is exactly what these maulvis are doing with us. They describe the Mahdi and the Messiah with the description that is necessarily that of prophethood. When we say: then why do you not say ‘prophet’?, (they say:) you say it, we do not. This is not justice, it is not right. Why do you quarrel over naming the reality you accept, and why do you give an interpretation of the Holy Qur’an that conflicts with that reality? Therefore the solution is that very verse I had presented. […] This is the Ummah of Muhammad. He will take pride in the companionship who is granted belonging (?) to this Ummah. Whoever will be with Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), whoever will be with the servants of Muhammad, the Messenger of Allah (saw), for them it is an honour – not that it would be an honour for them to be with Moses (as) and the earlier prophets. This is the true reality of Khatam-un-Nabiyyin, and this is our belief.