1. The first question is from Mehdi Hasan Sahib, who has come from [place name unclear]; he does not wish to come forward himself: What is the greatest proof of the Oneness of Allah and of His existence?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 25 February 1996

AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense

Question: The first question is from Mehdi Hasan Sahib, who has come from [place name unclear]; he does not wish to come forward himself: What is the greatest proof of the Oneness of Allah and of His existence?

The greatest proof is the Prophets themselves; no greater proof can be conceived. Actually every human being is also a proof in himself, if he reflects on his own self and asks: What am I, for what purpose have I come, who am I, what is my ego? Why was I granted the power of thought, when there is no law in chemistry or physics that can produce the power of thought? If a person examines these few simple things in his own existence, a personal proof can be provided to him from within his own being. But when you say the greatest proof, what is meant is one that can be presented to the whole world regardless, that can be set against opponents despite their opposition. That greatest proof is the existence of the Prophets. It has many aspects; if the whole subject were explained, one question would take up all the time. But I will put a few important points before you, so that it is not regarded as a mere claim, but so that whoever presents it can present it to others as a fact.

Of all the well-known Prophets whose history is preserved, not a single lie is proven in their lives before their claim, not even a single accusation of lying. From childhood until the claim, which usually comes after a fully lived youth, not even outsiders found a single stain on their chastity and purity. All the Prophets in their earlier lives were people on whom all eyes were fixed. They never lied about any person, never showed greed, never amassed wealth, never even strove for leadership; they did not even enter contests for leadership. When they suddenly say that we have received a message from God and it is this, then the most astonishing thing is how it is psychologically possible that a person who is trustworthy in people's affairs, acting without selfish desire, with no proven ambition for greatness, should suddenly start attributing a lie to God. If there is no God, the necessary conclusion is that he used God's name for some other purpose; no other explanation emerges. And if that is so, he is the greatest liar of his time. Such a sudden transformation, that the most truthful among people suddenly becomes the worst liar among them, human nature cannot accept.

But not only that: when, hiding some other desire in his heart, he claimed to be sent by God, he knows better than anyone that there is no God — if there is none, no one knows it better than he does. For such great audacity to lie about God would not have been possible for him unless he were fully convinced in this matter that the Being to whom he attributes the lie does not exist; otherwise He is Powerful, Mighty, and could uproot him [sense reconstructed]. Such a person, who gradually progresses on this journey of atheism, leaves traces of atheism behind. Such conversations take place in his gatherings, his gatherings become witnesses: this was the man who used to mock religion, who used to speak against the existence of God. Without such a psychological journey, such a leap is impossible. Whoever makes a claim should use his reason: how can it be that a person becomes an atheist, and suddenly, and an atheist of such a degree that there is none like him in the whole society, and then with great audacity puts forward a claim in the name of a fictitious being for the sake of his own greatness? That is the second question.

The third question is: when he does so, why does he destroy with his own hands the very greatness for whose sake he did it, and annihilate its prospects? For when he makes the claim — and this is the established history of the Prophets — even his own people abandon him, his friends become enemies, his own family thirsts for his blood. This is correct and certain. Then he shattered with his own hand the very purpose for which he had made the claim. Then he should have thought and reflected: I have needlessly taken a calamity upon myself. If not from today's politicians, he could have learned from the politicians of that time who, after making a statement, when the expected reaction did not come, repentantly backtracked: No, you did not understand me at all; when did I say that God made me something and raised me for a purpose? Yet alone against the whole society, watching his own become strangers and strangers become even greater enemies, he remains firm on his claim. What support stands by him in that hard time? If he were not certain that God exists, it would be impossible for him to play this role. Then he declares: I alone am left, and my God is with me; exert yourselves, use all your powers, you will not be able to wipe me out. And that is exactly what happens.

If you develop this subject further, you will be amazed that no reasonable person with even a little intelligence can bring any harm or attach any blemish to a Prophet's claim of faith in Allah. It is a claim above every kind of doubt. And throughout the whole world of Islam, the world of religion, throughout its history, this appears uniformly: from Adam to Noah, after Noah comes Abraham's turn; from Abraham, leaving out the other Prophets, come to Moses, go on to Jesus; and if you keep in mind all the Prophets in between, it is one continuous history running side by side with the history of human civilisation, and it is certain; you will see no deviation in it. And this has happened everywhere in the world. Come to India and we see the person of Krishna, despite all opposition. I am not speaking of the Krishna whom Hindus regard as God, but of the Krishna about whom a hadith says: ‘Kāna fil-Hindi nabiyyun, ismuhū Kāhin’ — there was a Prophet in India whose name was Kahin. And Kisan, Krishan, Kanhaiya and Kahin are in fact the same name pronounced in different ways. Leave this discussion aside. My point is: Muslims have no choice but to accept the existence of some Prophet in India. If they say it was not Krishna, then let them show who else it was, because the Holy Qur’an says that We have sent Prophets to every part of the whole world, and in every age. In this respect the history of India also becomes a witness: he showed not the slightest wavering, even though very great powers had gathered against him. Then take the history of Hazrat Zoroaster, then of Hazrat Confucius. All the great nations established in the name of religion that are alive to this day and firmly established in the world — they all repeat the same history. When did they ever conspire? They never even met each other, their times were different, their countries separate. How is it possible that they all thought up the same scheme as a conspiracy and bloomed on the same pattern like a flower, every petal opening the way the other flowers' petals opened? This uniformity, this universal unity, though there was no contact between them — these are all subjects; as I said, I will state them briefly. If you reflect on them, the existence of the Prophets is the greatest proof of the truth of God, of the existence of God, and such a proof that no sensible person free from prejudice can reject it.

10 of 10 left today