2. Dr. Alamgir Sahib, a consultant cardiologist from Shepherd's Bush [originally from Lahore, Pakistan]: Nowadays there are many sects in which people declare that they are the true ones. First: if Mirza Sahib declared himself a prophet, how can that be confirmed? Anyone can stand up and say that, and five or six hundred thousand people can gather behind him, as you see in America and elsewhere that sects form like this. Second: when prophets came before, there was always some problem at the time which Allah had sent them to address. When he came, what problems were there that he had to declare himself a prophet? Why could he not do it otherwise?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 25 February 1996
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: Dr. Alamgir Sahib, a consultant cardiologist from Shepherd's Bush [originally from Lahore, Pakistan]: Nowadays there are many sects in which people declare that they are the true ones. First: if Mirza Sahib declared himself a prophet, how can that be confirmed? Anyone can stand up and say that, and five or six hundred thousand people can gather behind him, as you see in America and elsewhere that sects form like this. Second: when prophets came before, there was always some problem at the time which Allah had sent them to address. When he came, what problems were there that he had to declare himself a prophet? Why could he not do it otherwise?
First of all, ‘he had to declare himself a prophet’ indicates that he had made a plan: my work will only succeed if I present myself as a prophet, and then I will solve the problems. That is what it contains, isn't it; that seems to be the hidden assumption. It is implicit in the question; without it the question does not stand. Otherwise you would have directed the question at God, as to why God made him so. Obviously you do not accept that. I understand your point; you have the right; until proof is provided to you, how will you accept? That is why you used very careful language and said that he probably arose with the intention of reform, I have no doubt, but what need was there in this effort of reform to declare himself a prophet — point one. Point two: what was this reform effort for which he had formed an intention? These are the two branches of your question, correct.
As regards the need for reform, you said by way of introduction that there are many religious sects in the world and each claims to be true. Against this background I submit: even if the prophet had no need to call himself a prophet, in this situation God had the need that whomever He sent for the reform of the Muslim Ummah He should send commissioned. And this need is established from the Holy Qur’an and the Ahadith: when the age becomes corrupt, when the unity of the communities is shattered to pieces, when claims arise from every side that only our sect is true and all the others false, then all these voices are human voices, arising on the basis of human thought, the product of human reflection. Of all the movements active in the Islamic world today, not one has said that God made me and God appointed me. And they have groups behind them, as you said, and those groups give strength to that voice. But is it not a fact that in the history of religion, when hard days come, when nations scatter, when unity breaks, they can neither be united again into one unity through human effort, nor have they ever been? Because human disagreement rests on a basic human right: it is up to you, you draw this conclusion; it is up to me, I draw that one. You understand the verses of the Holy Qur’an this way, I understand them that way. Such a dispute, whether with reference to the Holy Qur’an or the Hadith, can never reach a logical conclusion. And each person has only a claim; it has no more standing than that. With this claim there is no argument for the truthfulness of the person, because against such claims nations do not unite in opposition. Maulana Maududi was opposed, true, but the whole world still regarded him as part of Islam. There was no such opposition that he was expelled from their ranks, and that despite their mutual differences the whole community united against one man. That has never happened, never in the history of religion. But when God sends someone, this happens.
So this was the need: when communities become corrupt, their reform is not possible without one sent by Allah. And in proof of the truthfulness of the one sent, this is the first proof, as I said before: previously he is liked among people, everyone's favourite, and despite this one night he makes such a claim that even his own leave him and he faces severe opposition. This is necessary for recognising his truthfulness. It does not mean that Allah puts His beloved through suffering without reason; without the testing of his truthfulness, a community of firm believers cannot gather around him. All the other movements, in which man did not use God's name, said: I understand from the study of the Holy Qur’an and Hadith that God presumably says this. They went no further. No one said that Allah Himself appointed us and instructed us to say this, and that this verse has this content, this meaning. Not a single one made such a claim. Therefore they did not face that opposition either, therefore neither their truthfulness nor that of their followers was tested. But when God raises someone, the twofold benefit is that the truthfulness of the prophet becomes manifest through his steadfastness, his selflessness, his firm adherence to his claim despite seeing everything slip away, and the next proof takes the form of hundreds of thousands. Everyone who enters this community comes through fire, not walking on a bed of roses. He is abused, fires of opposition are kindled against him, his properties are snatched away, often his parents disinherit him. This means that there is no longer only one testimony, one truthful person; many such people stand around him, each of whose character is a sign of his truthfulness. Had he not believed, had he not had complete confidence that there are signs of truth in this person, he would not have staked his whole world merely on the thought that he might perhaps be true. Without complete certainty a person cannot give away his world with his own hands, not even on the promise that I will go to Paradise; in the first place the thought of Paradise does not even arise — whether there is Paradise or not: those who stood by Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) did not do so because of the promise of Paradise, but because they recognised his truthfulness. After that it was impossible for them to let go of his hem. Thus one truthful person produced truthful people; opposition to one truthful person produced more truthful people, targets of opposition, who remained steadfast; no power can move them from their path. This is the second reason why God has to appoint someone Himself.
Further: those who accept the faith after these hardships do so purely for Allah's sake; then the signs of godly people are found in them. It cannot be that they give away their properties in God's name and then remain caught in the misfortune of corruption, continue being dishonest and the love of the world continues, because that would be a contradiction of character: on one hand giving up one's own possessions in God's name as if they had no value, on the other hand chasing the world again. That cannot be. So for the reform of society it is necessary; it is impossible for a corrupt society to be set right merely by founding parties. No one has ever seen this happen in the world, nor is it happening now. In Pakistan or elsewhere, how many great parties were founded, how much talk of religion there was, how grandly the establishment of a religion-bound government was announced! The history of Zia-ul-Haq is not very old. How many times was it attempted to force Muslims to pray, how many times was it said: give up indecency, come to Islam, now your law permits you to practise Islam as you wish, and the law gave full protection. Is the standard of honesty in Pakistan ten years ago the same as today? Has it not fallen down the precipice? Has not the whole country run headlong into immorality and indecency, as if someone were thrown down from a mountain peak? How can this stop? It cannot stop and has not stopped, because those who found parties in the name of religion do not have God's support. They have their own aims, they want to gather a following around themselves, and so they raise the cries that gather followings. But their followers, their murids, may abduct, loot, take the lives of children, rob mothers of their peace, do whatever they like, set houses on fire, abduct and demand money and, if it is not paid, sell the children [uncertain], or theft, robbery, abduction, murder — in mosques and outside mosques — how is the mullah able to sleep, why is his peace not shattered? It is obvious that all of them claim to speak for God: if you follow them, bow your heads before them, you are permitted to do whatever you want, no harm comes to your Islam; we will protect your Islam; who is he to look at you askance? But do not leave us; if you leave our sect, then we will teach you a lesson, otherwise not. So every sect leader has practically given his people every kind of free rein, and as a result Islam there is merely a name; the reality of Islam does not exist at all. If the reality of Islam existed, righteousness would be visible, the conditions in the markets would change, a man would not even think of casting an evil glance at another woman. Abducting and killing children — which Islam teaches this? Have the leaders behind whom these people stand ever taken notice, have they ever come out into the streets saying, we will not let this happen? Because if they came out into the streets saying, we will not let this happen, those very followers would come after them with stones. Their call is answered with ‘Labbaik’ only when they call to evil, when they call people to plunder others' property, to set fires; then the whole nation cries ‘Labbaik, Labbaik’ and gathers around them. Did any Messenger of God ever gather people around him in this name: come, I call you to set everyone's houses on fire, abduct children, rob them, devour the properties of orphans, plunder the wealth of widows, file false lawsuits, and think day and night only of the world, of building up properties, and if you do politics, then continuously the politics of lies, when you go to court, go armed with lies, otherwise there is no safety for you? Is this Islam? If not, you can see it quite openly. This is the basic difference: until someone comes appointed by God — call him a prophet or a non-prophet — one coming from God is essential; without him society cannot be reformed. And without passing through the paths of sacrifice, no nation is ever revived.
This is the difference we saw at the very beginning. As a comparison from a political situation I put before you: the Congress had worked for a long time, and the Muslim League lacked this effort; they had no such long history. When the two countries were established, their [India's] country immediately organised itself around its ideals and maintained them. But Pakistan, before one's eyes, has strayed from its destination. The reason is that there — may Allah envelop the Quaid-e-Azam in His mercy — it was the truthfulness, the resolve of this one man, who refused to bow his head before others and finally, despite religious opposition, created Pakistan. And now? Those experienced people who had laboured and earned Pakistan are no longer there, but those who had done their utmost to prevent Pakistan from being created have taken over the country in the name of religion. This is a game, a spectacle; this is the truth. To recognise these things no written argument is needed; there is an inner argument of the soul which the Holy Qur’an calls ‘Bayan’. God has given every soul the faculty of Bayan, meaning not the faculty of speech but of discernment, and by this faculty you can always distinguish truth from falsehood. So instead of a long, detailed discussion that would need much time, I submit about Hazrat Mirza Sahib that he passed the test which the earlier Prophets passed. He was at that time the most popular personality in India among non-mullahs, eyes were turned to him, articles praising him were written from the length and breadth of India. What happened to him one night that he gave up all he had attained and exposed himself to the world's wrath as the worst of men? He raised his head, and then God did not abandon him. Then the community began to gather around him, the severe opposition doubled, and the same is happening today. So there is only one way of reform, one prescription, which God has always used from Adam until today. You as a doctor know better that one repeats the prescription that has been proven by experience; a prescription that keeps proving unsuccessful, no sensible doctor would take up and ruin the lives of his patients. This prescription of forming popularity gatherings, establishing organisations, has been the custom of the religious world since ancient times, but it has never worked. The prescription of reform is the same: you will come along the paths of sacrifice, giving away whatever is in your hands, taking stones; then flowers will be showered upon you from God. Without this it is not possible.