3. Councillor Anand Patel from Newham, East London [originally from Maharashtra/Bombay]: Many people of your community live in our borough, and I have heard that they have endured many hardships and come here. Still, we do not get much information from them. I want to know why it is that, despite enduring oppression and abuse, you have not raised your voice to this day.

Urdu question-and-answer session, 25 February 1996

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: Councillor Anand Patel from Newham, East London [originally from Maharashtra/Bombay]: Many people of your community live in our borough, and I have heard that they have endured many hardships and come here. Still, we do not get much information from them. I want to know why it is that, despite enduring oppression and abuse, you have not raised your voice to this day.

This is a very important question. [After a brief exchange about the questioner's origin and accent:] Within your question lies hidden a sign of our truthfulness, which I want to show you. In bearing hardships in the name of God there is for us such a delight, and such an expectation from God, that we do not protest about it to the world — except in one case. And I want to make this very clear, because this question may also be in the minds of some Pakistanis: on one hand you say we implore God, on the other hand you are telling the whole world what is being done to you — why this contradiction? And if you are telling, why are you not telling the Indians, why everyone else? This question has become very interesting. We do tell, but we do not tell our Indian friends much. That is the actual situation. The reason is that we do not believe in taking political advantage in the name of religion, and do not consider it permissible. We know that a political enmity between Pakistan and India is heading towards its extreme. And most of the people you see in these countries, even if they have been naturalised, have eaten the salt of Pakistan's soil, their relatives are there; therefore they would not like us to lean on the country whose enmity with Pakistan is currently reaching its peak — the question of blame is not the issue, it is probably on both sides, but the enmity exists. They will have no interest in our religion, but they will certainly be interested in our putting facts before them, presenting proofs, and their playing it up in the world — not in order to support an oppressed people, but in order to strike at an enemy country. That is the danger we face. Otherwise, if India's own conduct in the sphere of human relations were above reproach, and we were sure that here they would not entangle matters, that they themselves truly sympathise with human values, support them, and do the same in their own country, then it would not be unlikely that we come to you as well. But we have not seen this; we have seen the opposite. In the Hindu-Muslim conflict going on in India, with what happened to the Babri Mosque — should we go to that nation and say our mosque in Mardan was demolished, the mosque in Quetta was treated so, such and such happened at that place? That is not right. Because where their own conscience could not protect their own values before their eyes, how would they fight for our values? Yes, there is a likelihood that they would use these facts for their own advantage. Therefore I do not like Ahmadis to place the gun on India's shoulder to achieve their aims. For when in my Friday sermons I criticise Pakistan for its atrocities, I criticise India too, and I have never spoken in a muted way; I criticise America too, and if England is involved, I criticise it too. I have never cared that speaking the truth before the government under whose shade I sit might harm me. For the protection of international truth it is necessary not to put one's religious affairs before the world for economic or political purposes, but to speak where it is necessary.

And why it becomes necessary, I will explain: in our history, this is not the first time we have been wronged. Since Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as) announced his claim from Qadian, the whole of history bears witness: continuously from that time, wherever Ahmadiyyat raised its head, wherever its seed was sown, every effort was made to trample it. In all of history you will never see the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat raising these matters before the world. The reason is that previously this was a matter connected with individual efforts; governments were not involved. The first time a government has been formally involved is the Government of Pakistan. And not merely in expressing prejudice — Afghanistan was also involved in that way — but through legislation it carried out the deprivation of Ahmadis of all their fundamental rights. Pakistan stands alone and distinct in this; no Arab country has done this. Therefore — in Arab countries excesses do occur, some people are imprisoned, we know it, it happens, one has to make sacrifices for religion — but when in Pakistan the government does this, we have to tell the world that this is a country that walks with its feet in two boats: it comes to you, demands its rights in the United Nations, goes to the other organisations of the world community and says we are standard-bearers of all the values we have signed, and in practice this is its conduct. It claims democracy, and in the name of democracy deprives the inhabitants of its own country of their basic human rights. So our protest is not merely about atrocities resulting from religious enmity; our protest is against this double standard, and this must come openly before the world: when you deal with this country, you should know that this is its character; put pressure on them, press them, so that basic human rights are restored; then let things carry on as they will. When have we ever gone to America and said, such and such a man was arrested yesterday, this and that was done, support him? I am against this on principle; I believe in a principled struggle. And as long as this legislation stands in Pakistan, which, trampling democracy, interfered in the matter of religion, whereas democracy does not permit interference in the name of religion at all — the concept does not exist anywhere — as long as it persists in this, we will continue this protest before the world, and this is our duty and our right. Do you understand? Thank you.

10 of 10 left today